Disertación/Tesis

Clique aqui para acessar os arquivos diretamente da Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFBA

2024
Disertaciones
1
  • EMMANOEL VICTOR LIMA MELO
  • BACK TO THE CAVE IN AN ETERNAL RETURN - THE ARCHETYPICAL ACTION OF THE COLLECTIVE UNCONSCIOUS IN THE BLOSSOMING OF THE WILL TO POWER

  • Líder : JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • EDUARDO RIBEIRO DA FONSECA
  • IVAN MAIA DE MELLO
  • JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • Data: 05-feb-2024


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The objective of this work is to understand how the uniqueness of the individual is conceived. Since the light of consciousness turned on, the human species has been compelled to deal with the dilemma between nature and culture. There are those who defend the idea that we are completely cultural, and the question that arises from this perspective is whether the individual does not have innate characteristics of their own. Based on Nietzsche's proposal to become what one is and Jung's concept of individuation, we seek answers to these questions and evaluate how much of Nietzsche Jung brings into the psychic system of his analytical psychology. The conquest of oneself is an object of study for both thinkers and based on this prerogative we will analyze their similarities and divergences. The Nietzschean Will to Power underlies all manifestations of reality and the Jungian Archetypes would be the equivalent of the structure that models these manifestations. Understanding the relationship between the Will to Power and the Archetypes is one of the crucial points of this research. These two concepts will serve as a basis for investigating what the individual of the human species brings with it as collective and individual characteristics.

2
  • Jorge Ricardo da Silva Valois
  • The Principle of Individuation in Duns Scotus' Metaphysics in Its Relations with Common Nature

  • Líder : MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANTONIO JANUNZI NETO
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • ROBERTA MAGALHAES MIQUELANTI
  • Data: 19-feb-2024


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present study has as subject the principle of individuation of Duns Scotus’ Metaphysics, aiming to understand what is and how such principle is part of composition of something for generating a unique being. Therefore, it studies the concept of common nature, from which one can understand the principle of individuation. Indeed, a being is not individuated from nothing, but from a common nature, that this same being shares with others beings of the same species.Thus, common nature is the basis in which the individuation occurs. The element that provides such individuation is called haecceity, because it is something unique and unrepeatable. Haecceity is something positive, since it is added to common nature; in view of this, it isn’t something negative, which would be characterized by the absence of something. Neither, haecceity is not a kind of accident or existence, but it is a key and indispensable element for the constitution of an individual being. Furthermore, for a more accurate understanding of this principle of individuation, it’s necessary not only to see the basis (common nature) upon which fall haecceity, but also as common nature and haecceity relate to each other to generate an individual being. The relationship between both elements is characterized by formal distinction, in which there is inseparability of the elements and conceitual independence between them. For all these reasons, to the comprehension of the Scotist principle of individuation, it’s necessary the study of the common nature, which enables the individuation, since it is like a base material to do so; it’s required also to understand the relation between common nature and individuation, in which there is not a process of assimilation or overlap.

3
  • JULIA COELHO GOMES SEIXAS DA FONSECA
  • BLUES AND EMANCIPATION IN ANGELA DAVIS

  • Líder : VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • IMACULADA MARIA GUIMARÃES KANGUSSU
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 20-feb-2024


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • Angela Davis's critical thinking is an important source for the uses of freedom and the comprehension of the limits. Even today, the freedom issue faces great precedents in philosophy. The main purpose of this dissertation is to explore the relationship between the blues and emancipation through Angela Davis, in an attempt to provide a reading that incorporates philosophical thinking, the use of music in the conception of the concept, and the practice of freedom. Proposing to connect to political and cultural dimensions, in the work Blues Legacies and Black Feminism, Davis develops a study that aims to analyze the trajectory of classic blues singers as contributors to the struggle for the emancipation of black people. Then, to delve into the proposed object and understand the analyses developed by Angela Davis regarding the blues and emancipation, the dissertation will be divided into three chapters: one is dedicated to discussing the general relationship between art and politics, the second to analyze the question of emancipation and the last to examine the blues in the philosopher's thoughts. At the end of this work, it aims to elucidate the hypothesis that the blues are related to emancipation by catalyzing the emancipatory process, through the creation of an autonomous sexual, creative, and conscious subjectivity of the collective struggle and the important role of black women, or better yet, which denies the imposed sensitivity by the slavery and dominant capitalist group. From the blues, a new consciousness is formed, and radical emancipation becomes a real possibility. Thus, it is a vision that sees music as a possibility of creating new subjects, who will be able to promote a conscious and collective denial of the established reality.

4
  • THAÍS DE ANDRADE FRAGAS
  • Subjectivity and Alterity in Simone de Beauvoir: A Study on the "Inescapable Human Madness"

  • Líder : VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • THANA MARA DE SOUZA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 20-feb-2024


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation aims to analyze the relationship between otherness and subjectivity through a comparison of the essays and novels of Simone de Beauvoir. Focusing on the role of childhood in the formation of the individual and its influence on otherness, this work seeks to highlight the significance of Beauvoir's philosophical contributions beyond gender discussions, aligning them with both existentialist and phenomenological inquiries. Additionally, the study particularly concentrates on two crucial aspects of the philosopher's works: literature as a means of philosophical expression and violence as a component of intersubjective relations. It is noteworthy in this context that Beauvoir's philosophical exploration is enriched by her distinctive perspective on violence, examining its role in human relationships. By exploring selected novels, especially "She Came to Stay", the study examines how Beauvoir uses literary expression to deepen her investigation into the proposed themes. The subtitle of the dissertation refers to a phrase used by Beauvoir in "Pyrrhus and Cineas" to assert the paradox between perceiving oneself as a free being while simultaneously experiencing the facticity of one's human condition.

5
  • TAIANE ANDRADE ORNELAS
  • Poverty in Hegelian social theory

  • Líder : LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • PEDRO GERALDO APARECIDO NOVELLI
  • HÉLIO ALEXANDRE DA SILVA
  • Data: 21-feb-2024


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The dynamics established through the modern expansion of industrial activity, when
    capitalism was in the initial phase of its development, determined changes in social, economic
    and political conditions, establishing a new code of conduct for individuals in society. In
    Fundamental Lines of the Philosophy of Law, Hegel diagnoses the pathologies in bourgeois
    civil society. If, on the one hand, the expansion of the market economy favors the
    accumulation of wealth, on the other hand, however, it also generates poverty. Our objective
    was to analyze the Hegelian conception of poverty in civil society. Poverty is a fundamental
    issue, as it calls into question the legitimization of rational ethical life and the actualization of
    freedom. Here, we retrace Hegel’s steps from his critical fortunes, to present his conception,
    that is, the concept, its effectiveness and possible solutions to poverty. In the first chapter, we
    present the Hegelian concept of poverty, as it necessarily emerges from the dynamics in civil
    society; in the second, we investigate the consequences of poverty as a loss of what
    constitutes the fundamental characteristic of modern times, the subjective freedom of the
    individual, their right to be recognized and honored as such and the guarantee of existing in
    and by society; Finally, we examine the solutions for overcoming poverty presented by Hegel
    and establish their limits.

2023
Disertaciones
1
  • SIMONE BORGES DOS SANTOS
  • Angela Davis and freedom as a constant struggle 

  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALAN DA SILVA SAMPAIO
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MARIA CRISTINA LONGO CARDOSO DIAS
  • Data: 30-ene-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation addresses Angela Davis' critique of “freedom,” focusing on a crucial problem she identifies: Freedom for Black men and women is limited, for it does not exist as a lived reality. Taking up this assertation, this project aims to investigate the mechanisms that capitalist systems utilize to limit the freedom of racialized groups. First, it examines how racialized peoples construct their own ethical-political relations when their freedom is  hindered by the invention of race and otherness. Second, it examines the conditions through which these people, who are objectified and marked by difference, can be recognised as rational subjects with desires and, above all, rights. This project demonstrates that “freedom qua the pillar of democracy,” a discourse used by neoliberal states, holds a contradiction. This contradiction is evident in the staggering number of human beings that are incarcerated daily. Capitalist democratic governments, motived by financial gain, use the fallacy of the “War on Drugs” to this end. These governments depend on racial oppression and limit the rights of some groups of people to secure the rights of others. The prison system transforms into a punishment industry that uses racism and xenophobia to supply prisons, disproportionately incarcerating Black people. Here, torture practices are used for bodily coercion and docility, although bodily torture is not generally permitted within these democratic insitutions. Still, women of color live through and resist these conditions. Black women in particular present abolitionist alternatives, allowing an understanding of other ethical-political possibilities. She has always been active in all emancipatory movements; she led marches against the lynchings of black men; she used, and uses, art to reveal pain, strength and the struggle to overcome. Because she is at the base of most hierarchies of oppressions, the task of freeing herself from subjugation and violence falls on her body. Her freedom is therefore freedom for others.

2
  • LUAN LUIZ PEREIRA BATISTA
  • The genesis of Friedrich Engels' dialectical conception of nature
    (1858-1873)

  • Líder : VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • JOSE ALCIMAR DE OLIVEIRA
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • OLIVAL FREIRE JUNIOR
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 03-feb-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This research inquires the genesis of Friedrich Engels' dialectical conception of nature. Exposed, in its general lines, in works such as the unfinished Dialectics of nature (1873-1882), the Anti-Dühring (1876-1878) and Ludwig Feuerbach and the end of Classical German Philosophy (1886-1888), it was formulated in the late 1850s and matured over the course of the 1860s, in constant contact with the natural sciences and philosophies of his time. The research follows the main moments of the genesis and development of this conception and the theoretical and ideopolitical context of each one of these moments. In the Introduction, we make methodological considerations, justify the scope and object of the research and present an overview of the issues surrounding Engels' dialectic of nature. In chapter 1, The insight of a dialectic of nature, we look into: 1) Engels' finding that new scientific discoveries attested to the occurrence of dialectical phenomena in nature; 2) his description to Marx, in his letter of July 14, 1858, of these phenomena – the documentary mark of the then nascent dialectical conception; and 3) the philosophical repercussions of such a finding, especially the outlines of a theoretical program that, even if it did not materialize at that moment in a proper writing project, would direct his subsequent scientific and natural-philosophical studies towards the foundation of a materialistic natural dialectic. Finally, in chapter 2, The “natural-historical basis for our views”: the Engelsian reception of Darwin's work, we follow, from the impact that the theory of evolution of species had on Engels' thought, the development of his dialectical conception throughout the 1860s, until its culmination, in a letter to Marx of May 30, 1873, in a project to write a Dialectics of nature.

3
  • BETHANIA ALVES PEREIRA DE SOUZA
  • Political Cartography of Judith Butler: between subjectivities and identities

  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CRISTIANE MARIA MARINHO
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • Data: 24-feb-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation has as a purpose to examine the hypothesis according to the destabilization of the subject of identity presented by the philosopher Judith Butler could provide fundamental openings or cracks to an radical action and discourse, exceeding the politics of identity. The critic of the gender subject, fundamental to the identity politics of feminism, provoque a debate based on the category of “Women”. Butler refutes gender identity in its metaphysical sense and proposes an approach of it as an performative notion. Her thought, however, takes a normative turn from the 2000’s on, which makes her deepen the concept of performative identity under an ethical approach. In this way, the philosopher proposes as a foundation of life’s value and its exposition the precarious condition of life. Bearing in mind the grounding of life's value and its exposition to the precariousness, Butler goes beyond her performative gender theory, proposing a theory of collective and plural performativity, thinking bodies gathered together in assembly. Thus, this work has as structure the discussion of the history of the subject of law and his development in modern political theory, and then to starts an investigation about the category of subject in contemporaneity. Thereafter, it discusses, too, the critique of the gender ontology of Beauvoir, followed by the elaboration of performative identity of gender. And finally this dissertation is ended by the reflection of the normative turn of Butler’s work, from the concepts of grief and precariousness, and how these concepts could help (or not) to think a convergence point to the contemporary struggles that transcends the identity subject.

4
  • Jordânia Barbosa Araújo
  • Suicide and Individuality in Karl Marx

  • Líder : MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANTONIO DA SILVA CAMARA
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 20-mar-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This work aims to examine the human individuality involved in the phenomenon of suicide from the perspective of Karl Marx. Many interpreters conceive the essay On Suicide (2006) as an untimely text by Marx. However, it seeks to problematize that it is not a writing that presents disagreement with the whole of this philosopher's work, starting, among other aspects, with the literary style used. Furthermore, there are also epigones who strive to produce the image of an economistic Marx, who would have dissolved human subjectivity in strictly economic processes. In contrast to these readings, it is intended to demonstrate the philosopher's heuristic concern about human individuality and its implication in the phenomenon of suicide, based on the debate on alienation, detachment, patriarchy and loneliness

5
  • CELESTE COSTA DE SOUZA
  • Dialectics of Freedom in Angela Davis

  • Líder : ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • ANGELA LUCIA SILVA FIGUEIREDO
  • LAIZ FRAGA DANTAS
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 14-jul-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present work aims to analyze freedom from the perspective of Angela Davis and the experience of black populations in the diaspora, as a historical-dialectical movement located in the context of modern slavery. The social relations arisen from slave labor were the cradle of birth of wage labor, the development of industrial capitalism and modern racism. Thus, it is pertinent to understand the centrality of alienated work for the dissemination of a reified reality that reproduces the racist stereotypes shared by the culture, reinforced by the institutional practices. They organize society and reproduce the subalternity of groups that are racially identified, mainly black women. Freedom thus asserts itself, as a constant process of disalienation and empowerment, through the denial of alienated work and racism, through the performance, mainly, of the work of black women, in the constant struggle for the dignity of the family and continuity of life, having in abolitionist feminism, in sensitive and aesthetic education, practical strategies for the abolition of capitalist institutions..

6
  • Margareth Rodrigues Coêlho Vaz
  • REDISTRIBUTION AND RECOGNITION IN NANCY FRASER: A DEMOCRATIC CHALLENGE FOR CRITICAL THEORY

  • Líder : LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DENISE CRISTINA VITALE RAMOS MENDES
  • LAIZ FRAGA DANTAS
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • RENATO FRANCISQUINI TEIXEIRA
  • Data: 14-ago-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The approach about the concepts of redistribution and recognition, by philosopher Nancy
    Fraser, exposes the democratic challenge of critical theory to break with the profile of
    explaining the functioning of capitalist society and its social problems through hermetic and
    monolithic perspectives of social theories. Within this framework, the thinker develops a
    conceptual model capable of absorbing both the structures of social domination and the social
    resources necessary for its practical overcoming. To this end, she defends a two-dimensional
    conception of justice as participatory parity, articulating redistribution and recognition, based
    on the Habermasian paradigm of the theory of communicative action and on Honneth's theory
    of recognition. Fraser undertakes to reflect on the normative dynamics of objective and
    intersubjective relations, considering the feasibility of connecting critique and crisis and social
    struggle, using the feminist struggle and the point of view of feminist critical theory as an
    empirical reference. In this paper, we investigate how Fraser assumes the concepts of
    redistribution and recognition, Fraser’s concept of popular paradigms of justice, the problem of
    false antithesis, the model of recognition as status and the participatory parity paradigm. We
    analyze the critiques to the two-dimensional project of justice, considering her debates with
    Axel Honneth and Iris Young, about the perspective dualism, and with Rainer Forster, about
    the participatory parity.

7
  • DIEGO DE SOUZA HIRATA
  • The Problem of Justification of Causality of the Philosophy of David Hume

  • Líder : MARIANA DE ALMEIDA CAMPOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • MARIANA DE ALMEIDA CAMPOS
  • MARÍLIA CÔRTES DE FERRAZ
  • Data: 04-oct-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The human reason is divided into three kinds: the first from knowledge, the second from
    probabilities, and the third from proofs. The first one arrives from comparison of ideas and it is
    not subject to the experience’s scrutiny. The other two kinds of reasoning are formed by matter
    of facts, whose argumments are based on causes and effects, and any evidency of their
    jugdments must appeal to experience. The reasonings from knowlegde, or demonstrative
    reasonings, are justified by reason and its propositions are intuitively certain. The reasonings
    from probabilities, or probable reasonings, it does not has the same sucess. Based on
    probabilities, they consider the chances that the same object has to provide the same result. Due
    the lack of evidence and for not beying able to intuitively demonstrate their judgments, they
    can only judge about the conjectures of existence. As I will argue throughout this dissertation,
    probable reasonings are incapable of justifying their arguments. Consequently, the hypothesis
    that I will assume is that the reasonings from proofs is the only way to justify causality
    arguments. Therefore, I will first examine Hume’s theory of perception, in order to show
    knowlegde’s structure and the nature of impressions and ideas that conceive the reasonings.
    This inicial exam will serve to, posteriorly, examine the foundations of causal reasoning. As
    such, in a second moment, I will examine Hume’s arguments about the principles of human
    nature that associate perceptions on the imagination. I will then argue that this principles, when
    recognized as proofs, explain all the logic employed in causal reasoning, and thus justify
    arguments from causality.

8
  • ALEX NASCIMENTO ANDRADE DOS SANTOS
  • Altruistic suicide: Sacrifice for pure love in Schopenhauer's philosophy

  • Líder : JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • VILMAR DEBONA
  • JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • KLEVERTON BACELAR SANTANA
  • Data: 09-oct-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The objective of this dissertation is to analyze the possibility of altruistic suicide being a virtuous action from the point of view of Schopenhauerian philosophy. The philosopher considers suicide to be senseless and affirms that it is an action of affirmation of the Will. If the human being has the tendency to affirm the Will in a egocentric and purely individual way, his original attitudes are selfish. In view that Schopenhauer considers only the ascetic suicide (by inanition) as the only way to choose death, indeed, with any moral value, because it is the denial of the Will itself, the research aims to achieve answers to some questions, such as: would it be immoral the case in which, by an act of pure compassion and altruism, someone would choose to die for the survival of another person? The philosopher, in On the basis of morality, proposes that deeds of compassion are the only basis for a moral attitude. Compassion (as well as asceticism), is the negation of one's voracious will, therefore, it is essentially moral. Can it be that one who sacrifices his own life for someone else is acting compassionately?

9
  • José Carlos Silva Rocha Costa
  • NIETZSCHE AND GENEALOGICAL INQUIRY AS PROJECT OF NATURALIZATION OF MORALITY

  • Líder : ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • WILSON ANTONIO FREZZATTI JUNIOR
  • ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • Data: 04-dic-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The question to which this research aims to provide a coherent and adequate answer to the Nietzschean philosophical project can be formulated as follows: what does the new requirement announced by Nietzsche in the prologue to the Genealogy of morals mean, according to which “we need a critique of moral values, that the value of values itself must be called into question?” (GM/GM §6). In this paper, we argue that genealogy is configured as a regressive investigation into the origins of values, which is opposed to the search for metaphysical "essences" and ahistorical truths and is closely identified with a notion of process. We understand that this mode of investigation is typical of a philosophy of interpretation that uses genealogical- naturalistic tools and seeks to replace the problem of truth with the problem of value. We will analyze the concept of historical meaning as an anthropological interpretation, that is, as an instrument of evaluation that occupies an important place within the naturalist program of the Genealogy of morals. In addition, we will highlight the idea that the Nietzschean program does not ignore the scientific discoveries of the intellectual milieu in which the philosopher is inserted. Although we understand that Nietzsche does not propose reducing philosophical reflection to a scientific view of reality, we understand that philosophical activity is enriched by a diversified view, including an honest approach to dialog with the natural sciences. The scope of the research that follows consists of studying genealogy as a procedure that puts values into question, when it asks what value values have. As a result, the main theses of the Genealogy of morals will be discussed, i.e. the inversion of values, the psychology of resentment, bad conscience and the critique of the ascetic ideal, in parallel with the concept of the transvaluation of all values.

10
  • HENRI MARCEL DE OLIVEIRA SÃO PAULO
  • WHAT IS A PERSON? WILFRID SELLARS' SYNOPTIC PROJECT

  • Líder : WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • SOFIA INÊS ALBORNOZ STEIN
  • GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • Data: 07-dic-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present dissertation aims to approach the concept of personhood according to Wilfrid S. Sellars’s synoptic project of unification of the manifest and scientific images of the person-in-the-world. Our approach is particularly informed by the kantian themes present in Sellars’s work. We first approach the concept of knowledge and Sellars’s classical critique of the “myth of the Given”, to defend a theory of knowledge under a practical conception, thus leading us to confront the problem of the relation between mind and world in relation to this practice. Such problem leads us to the conflict between the manifest and scientific images of the person-in-the-world, as images which highlight respectively the normative and descriptive aspects of personhood. We thus propose a unified image by means of a reinterpretation of Kant’s principle of unity of apperception, to the principle of practical unity of personhood, concluding with a formulation of the concept of a person as that of a complex physical system which realizes irreducible logical subjects.

Tesis
1
  • Carlos Augusto de Oliveira Carvalhar
  • TOPICS OF POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY IN PLATO: A CONTEMPORARY APPROACH

  • Líder : DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CAMILA DO ESPÍRITO SANTO PRADO DE OLIVEIRA
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • LUISA SEVERO BUARQUE DE HOLANDA
  • PAULO BUTTI DE LIMA
  • Data: 12-jul-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This is a thesis that follows the path indicated by Mario Vegetti, in understanding the figure of the political Plato in relation to the ideological issues that influence the interpretation of Plato's own texts, mainly using three dialogues: The Republic, The Laws, and The Statesman. Due to this critical approach, the first part provides a brief overview of the main arguments criticized since antiquity, from Aristophanes' comedy and Aristotle's refutation to Neoplatonism and the Byzantine period, but jumping straight to the 20th century and the Cold War, which contributed to the formation of biased readings based on the political thought of commentators such as Karl Popper and Leo Strauss. I also highlight the themes of Ancient History that were influenced by Karl Marx's philosophy, particularly the concept of social class employed in ancient societies.

    Therefore, it is an exploratory research that follows a thematic axis of analysis, based on topics that still pique our contemporary curiosity, which are interdependent and intertwined at various points, aiming to better understand the main aspects of political issues in Plato. The discussion thus covers various subjects, such as the manifestation of power through persuasive discourse or necessary coercion through violence; the legitimacy of authority and the role of guardians and lawmakers; ideology and models of the city, ranging from the paradigm of the Callipolis to Magnesia; criticism of democracy in relation to emotions and the parallel between the soul and the city; Greek colonization and its influence on the development of a normative utopia for the foundation of future societies where justice would be better distributed; gender equality and the abolition of the traditional family model; criticism of property and the communism of goods; and finally, slavery and the disdain for manual labor.

    As a consequence, the theoretical distinctive feature of this work lies in the historical contextualization carried out in addressing Platonic Political Philosophy. This approach ensures an understanding of Plato within the limits of his time, without falling into shallow anachronism or idealizing the author. It highlights the shared experience among Greek authors of the classical period in relation to the temporal frame of reference they possessed.

2
  • JOELSON SANTOS NASCIMENTO
  • The Stoic concepto of Pathos: from Zeno to Chrysippus

  • Líder : ALDO LOPES DINUCCI
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALDO LOPES DINUCCI
  • GABRIELE CORNELLI
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MARCUS DE AQUINO RESENDE
  • MARIANA CONDÉ
  • Data: 27-jul-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The aim of this work is to investigate the Stoic concept of  pathos  in Zenoand  Chrysippus. We  will  work  with these  two  authors  because  they  pro-vided a basis for the concept of pathos used by later Stoic philosophers, inaddition to a change in conceptual route. For this purpose, we will use assources  the  fragments  of  the  old Stoics,  found  in  the  Stoicorum VeterumFragmenta.

3
  • DOUGLAS LISBOA SANTOS DE JESUS
  • Between Logic and Rhetoric: the axiomatizations of euclidean geometry in XVI and XVII centuries

  • Líder : ABEL LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ABEL LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • JORGE ALBERTO MOLINA
  • FRANK THOMAS SAUTTER
  • WAGNER DE CAMPOS SANZ
  • Data: 06-oct-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis aims to present the debate on the nature of Euclidean geometric demonstrations
    throughout the 16th and 17th centuries. It starts by examining the reception of the Platonic
    philosopher Proclus' comments on Euclid's Elements and the tradition of demonstrative
    science presented in Aristotle's Posterior Analytics . At the heart of this debate is a dispute
    about the relevance of certain rhetorical concepts in light of the alleged limitations of
    syllogistics in accounting for how mathematicians typically demonstrate their propositions.
    The mathematical practice inferred from the Elements allows for a coordination between two
    types of justifications, one provided by linguistic means and the other by diagrams, primarily
    but not exclusively aimed at solving geometric problems. The establishment of a
    logical-linguistic definition of demonstration, heavily influenced by David Hilbert, resulted in
    the dispensability of diagrams. The axiomatizations of what was understood as Euclidean
    geometry in the 16th and 17th centuries, for the most part, were embedded in Aristotle's
    doctrine of demonstrative science. From this perspective, the tradition of problem-solving is
    secondary. Nevertheless, Aristotle believed that demonstrations should satisfy both logical
    and epistemological criteria in equal measure. Unlike 20th-century philosophy of
    mathematics, Aristotle's conception of demonstration was not solely concerned with logical
    consequence. However, the syllogistic reconstruction of Euclidean demonstrations was not the
    primary goal, especially since Proclus raised doubts about the power of Aristotelian logic.
    The crisis of the Aristotelian scientific method paved the way for the exploration of
    alternative approaches, including rhetoric. Most commentators on the Euclidean text during
    this period assumed that the demonstrations in the Elements were intentionally abbreviated,
    allowing them to speak of enthymemes, i.e. , rhetorical syllogisms. The inclusion of new
    axioms not covered in Proclus' text, many of which anticipated Hilbert's formal axiomatic
    method, makes it possible to restore the complete version of the demonstration without
    implying that the abbreviated version, i.e. , enthymematic, is considered illegitimate.

4
  • ANA MARY COSTA BISPO
  • Original time as foundation of dynamic of factical life

  • Líder : ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • ADRIELLE COSTA GOMES DE JESUS
  • DENISE MAGALHÃES DA COSTA
  • DIOGO CAMPOS DA SILVA
  • THIAGO ANDRE MOURA DE AQUINO
  • Data: 05-dic-2023


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The objective of the present thesis is to analyze the reasons why time is commonly interpreted as movement in everyday life. To do so, we will turn to the philosophy of Martin Heidegger, for whom time is what gives meaning to human life. In this way, time is indelibly correlated with life, as it is in the common discourse about daily experiences that time as movement becomes transparent as that which passes, is irreversible, continuous, and unlimited. Analyzing time from the heideggerian perspective also involves delving into Aristotle's thoughts on time; for this philosopher, everyday time is a flow of continuous “nows”, where the current “nows” is interconnected with subsequent and preceding “nows”. In this sense, the “nows” are stretched between the “then”, the posterior, and the “before”, the anterior. Heidegger sees Aristotle's concept of time as the time expressed in everyday life. Through the interconnection of life, time, and movement, we aim to analyze the correlation between the dynamics of life and its relationship with everyday time as movement, in order to reach the original foundations of this mode of time.

2022
Disertaciones
1
  • TIAGO SABÓIA MACHADO
  • Descriptive methodology and models of knowledge in juridical positivism

  • Líder : ABEL LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ABEL LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • FRANK THOMAS SAUTTER
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • Data: 18-feb-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis is a brief study on legal positivism, a branch of legal theory and philosophy that emerged approximately two hundred years ago. More specifically, the work discusses one of its central theses, which affirms that the existence of a law does not depend on its moral value but the occurrence of socially verifiable facts such as the presence of authority and the generalized obedience of the group (separability thesis). Once we met these requirements, a system would be recognized as legal even if morally objectionable. But this task, in turn, depends on a method that provides objective criteria for identifying and describing the law. From this arise at least two different methodological proposals within positivism, the naturalist and normativism. The analysis of these models and the type of legal knowledge we can obtain through them constitutes the core of this work. Therefore, it is composed of three chapters. The first offers a general approach to legal positivism through a counterpoint to the millenary Natural Law tradition and its thesis that the law is not a neutral phenomenon but depends on a moral basis to exist (morality thesis). The second chapter turns to the exam to the naturalist and normativism methodological variants, through the analysis of the works of its leading figures, respectively, John Austin and Hans Kelsen. Finally, the third chapter resumes the discussion about the difference assumed by a positivist epistemology between the functions of describing and evaluating the law through a synthesis of the contemporary debate between H.L.A. Hart and Ronald Dworkin in which this theme plays a central role.

2
  • KARINE BOAVENTURA RENTE SANTOS

  • THE COMMUNAL IDENTITY AS A GENERATIVE PROBLEM IN HUSSERL’S PHENOMENOLOGY

  • Líder : CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • SCHEILA THOMÉ
  • MARCELO FABRI
  • CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • Data: 07-jun-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation addresses the communal identity as an object of the generative method. Before dealing with the primary objective of the research, the dissertation clarifies some relevant points. First, it demystifies intersubjectivity as a theme of Husserlian phenomenology through the analyses of Husserl's cartesianism. Second, it states the ways Husserl used to describe intersubjectivity. Third, it defines the structure of history as generative synthesis. Once these three objectives wore fulfilled, it is possible to refer to the community that has an identity as an intersubjective form, which is necessarily social-historical nature and needs to be studied in accordance with its constitution.  The community that has an identity phenomenologically inquired has its genesis investigated. It appears as social-historical genesis established throughout generations. These generations are described as working together to preserve and transform the heritage they receive as being part of a community.

3
  • LUCAS JAIRO CERVANTES BISPO
  • EPISTEMOLOGY OF IGNORANCE: ON THE NATURE OF PROPOSITIONAL IGNORANCE

  • Líder : GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • ARTHUR VIANA LOPES
  • ALEXANDRE MEYER LUZ
  • Data: 03-oct-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • In this work, I discuss the nature of propositional ignorance, the possibility of non-factive ignorance and the applicability of this analysis to some topics of analytic epistemology. My intention is, first, to present a critical introduction to the discussion between two relevant alternatives that dispute the definition of ignorance, namely, the Standard View and the New View. For the former, ignorance is the absence of knowledge; for the second, the absence of true belief. Considering this divergence, each of these alternatives will be exposed given how they define ignorance and the specific conditions for propositional ignorance. Furthermore, both conceptions of propositional ignorance will be briefly contrasted based on some topics present in the current debate. Second, I intend to point out that, unlike how these conceptions of ignorance are presupposed, propositional ignorance is not reduced to the structure “S is ignorant that P” or similar variants of this structure. Reading propositional ignorance reduced in terms of "S is ignorant that P", these views do not make the best analysis of propositional ignorance. This is because, on the one hand, they generate a problem that refers to a possibility that has been little worked on. It is about the possibility of non-factive ignorance and the problem, as will be shown, is that in this reduction there are good reasons both to affirm and to deny this possibility. This constitutes, at least, as a relevant theorical tension that can compromise these conceptions and the analyzes carried out based on them. On the other hand, this reduction excludes at least a general and not necessarily factual sense of propositional ignorance, which deprives us of a more adequate analysis of ignorance and other related issues. Having this problem and its consequences in view, I will point to a hypothesis that has the potential to dissolve it by reformulating how we understand propositional ignorance, inheriting the advantages of reasons in favor and of reasons against the possibility of non-factive ignorance and overcoming the objections raised against them. In addition, finally, this reformulated analysis of propositional ignorance will be applied to some relevant topics of analytic epistemology that are essentially relate to ignorance, but which have not been sufficiently debated in this relationship to ignorance, namely, education, suspension of judgment and investigation. In this application, I will be aiming at a clarification of these relationships and showing that there are other ways to point out the adequacy of this reformulation. Thus, this work aims to contribute to the dissemination in Portuguese of a recent but growing discussion in analytical epistemology, as well as to the theoretical development in this area.

4
  • JEAN MARCELO DOS SANTOS FARAOH
  • ANALYSIS OF THE CATEGORICAL IMPERATIVE AND KANT'S FREEDOM

  • Líder : JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • VALERIO HILLESHEIM
  • Data: 15-dic-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The categorical imperative is the central idea formulated by Kant in order
    to analyze what motivates human action and understand both morals and ethics. How
    an individual acts on the basis of principles he would like to see applied is the maxim
    and could become what Kant calls universal law. Acting based on duty (in this case,
    based solely on the supreme principle of morality) goes beyond the concept of doing
    what you would like to be done, since your attitude must be free of any interest and
    always have an end in itself. same. It is above moral relativism in which what is correct
    depends on the situation and context in which the subject finds itself, being beyond
    subjectivity, as it can be applied to everyone. At its core is “doing what I would like
    everyone to do with everyone”, assuming that your actions will be right if they can
    become a universal law followed by the collectivity. Kant's categorical imperative is
    based on statements that complement each other, guiding the way in which morally
    correct conduct is analyzed: 1. "Act as if the maxim of your action should become,
    through your will, a universal law”. 2. “Act in such a way that you use humanity both in
    yourself and in the person of anyone else, always and at the same time, as an end and
    never as a means”. 3. "Act in such a way that your will can face itself, at the same time
    as a universal legislator through maxims." Taking these statements as a starting point,
    the categorical imperative is understood as a moral duty that must absolutely reach
    everyone. Such a precept is the end in itself and cannot have external justification. Its
    objective is to escape the subjective aspects of utilitarianism and understand that the
    moral value of actions is closely linked to the agent's motivation and not to the
    consequences of any rational agent's act. An action will be morally correct if the
    motivation for the agent's conduct is free from any internal or external interest. Thus,
    the morally correct act can be analyzed by the procedure of establishing the maxim to
    be evaluated (the Principle of Action) and presupposing the transformation of this
    maxim into universal law, verifying the consequences of its universalization and
    ascertaining whether the moral agent would accept the consequences of transforming
    their conduct into a universal law followed by all. Thus, the categorical imperative ends
    up valuing the intrinsic value of conduct, the fulfillment of duty driven only by the correct
    decision to be taken impartially and disinterestedly respecting the value and humanity
    of each rational being and acting according to maxims that everyone could embrace
    and practice. The idea of the reason that determines the imperative as it is is about
    Freedom. For Kant, freedom is the autonomy to fulfill one's duty in accordance with the
    Laws of Nature. “By “moral freedom” must be understood, according to Kant, the
    faculty of adaptation to the laws that our reason gives to ourselves; by “juridical
    freedom”, the faculty of acting according to the external world, not being impeded by
    the equal freedom of other human beings, free like me, internally and externally”.
    These are two important concepts that govern the Kantian theory of morality. The
    objective of this work is to analyze these concepts, their relationships and their
    implications, with a special focus on the books Groundwork for the Metaphysics of
    Morals and The Critique of Practical Reason.

5
  • AYRONNE SANTOS SOUZA
  • PLATO'S MENON: VIRTUE FROM A HYPOTHESIS
  • Líder : GISLENE VALE DOS SANTOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALDO LOPES DINUCCI
  • ALESSANDRA CARBONERO LIMA
  • GISLENE VALE DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 15-dic-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation does not aim to define virtue (areté), but to examine how Plato understands an investigation that has as its starting point a hypóthesis similar to those used by geometers. Although virtue is a problematized theme - even if indirectly - in practically the entire Corpus Platonicum, it will be thematized, in this research, having as its primary basis the dialogue Meno, more precisely, from the excerpt 86c - when the homonymous character to the dialogue gives up trying to define virtue and returns to its first question - namely, whether virtue can be taught. As the investigation into virtue now has a hypóthesis as its starting point, we will, beforehand, seek to understand what Plato thinks about the term hypótheses. Furthermore, considering that the dialogue, based on the assumption that virtue can be encompassed by episteme, provisionally concludes that phrónesis is virtue, we will examine the relationship between the terms epistéme and phrónesis. In a second moment, as there is an unfolding in the conclusion of the Meno, since virtue starts to be investigated from the empirical question and is considered as orthè dóxa, we will analyze the similarity between orthè dóxa and hypóthesis. In this way, we will see to what extent the investigation of virtue from a hypóthesis influences the outcome of the Meno. 

Tesis
1
  • GUSTAVO DAVID CARDOZO SANTIAGO
  • Motley Society and Hegemony: History and Politics in Andean Thinking

  • Líder : MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • FERNADO DANIEL LONGÁS URANGA
  • JOSÉ LUIS VILLACAÑAS BERLANGA
  • CRISTINA CATALINA GALLEGO
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 07-jun-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The core of our research is, strictly speaking, the issue of hegemony in the Andean world. The approach we have chosen to address this theoretical-political problem is not based on the analysis of this category from a firmly philological point of view nor have we chosen to draw a frame of modulations, uses and potentialities of the notion of hegemony, but we have drawn a political contour — understood as equivalent to the different historical efforts to build hegemony relations — in two countries strongly marked by the Hispanic colonial heritage: Bolivia and Peru. Therefore, our research is not only focused on the history and politics in those nations, but it does so by deploying, as the backbone of the narration, a critical dialogue with the historical approaches and political proposals that emerge from the intellectual production of two of the most important Latin American Marxists of the twentieth century: the Peruvian José Carlos Mariátegui and the Bolivian René Zavaleta Mercado. The approach to the question of hegemony in the Andean world required questioning the effectiveness of the colonial heritage. Actually, to establish the framework of the hegemony issue, was required a prior genealogical explanation that would account for the motley condition [abigarramiento] on which any political project had to be based in the Andean region. Consequently, we could say that what René Zavaleta Mercado categorized as motley society [formación social abigarrada] and which in a schematic way we could characterize as the disarticulated coexistence of different modes of production, ideological patterns, domination structures and, in short, the simultaneity of temporalities out of sync in the same economic, political, and social scenario, decisively marked the various political projects in the region. Simultaneously, the motley condition —in the particular case that concerns us, the Andean world— could not be understood but as the result of the successive agreements and disagreements between uneven human groups: since the expansion of the Inca Empire, followed by the Conquest and the erection of the Viceroyalty of Peru, interceded by the expansion of commercial capitalism, the Latin American independence processes, the consolidation of the national oligarchies, the irruption of the capitalist mode of production in regional enclaves and so many other factors to which this research dedicates its pages. Ultimately, the motley condition does not refer exclusively to centrifugal tendencies, but also to those centripetal tendencies of attraction to the centers of power (economic, political, religious, etc.): the unresolved tensions between centrifugal and centripetal tendencies illustrate what is at stake with the notion of motley society. The crossroad is evident: if the motley condition indicates the tendency to the disarticulation of the different and, consequently, deepens the separation between the parties; hegemony, on the other hand, consists basically in the construction of a unity between the ruler and the ruled. Thus, as the 16 motley condition is constituted by the tension between centrifugal and centripetal tendencies that determine the normal functioning of power relations, between the separatist ratification of difference and the integrationist drive represented by identity, in the hegemony is also perceptible the tension that configures the metonymic link between the part and the whole, inseparable conflict of all political construction with hegemonic aspirations. These tensions between the notions of motley society and hegemony will appear again and again throughout our research and not only from a theoretical prism centered on the description of the elements that make up the semantic field of these categories, but also —and fundamentally— from the analysis of the historical ambiguities and the strategic instability of the political commitment of an Andean Marxism that finds in the works of Mariátegui and Zavaleta Mercado its most accomplished formulation

2
  • MARIA DO SOCORRO GONÇALVES DA COSTA
  • The construction of a pedagogical anthropology in Rousseau: from the Second Discourse to Emile
  • Líder : GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CUSTÓDIA ALEXANDA ALMEIDA MARTINS
  • WILSON ALVES DE PAIVA
  • THOMAZ MASSADI KAWAUCHE
  • GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • ISRAEL ALEXANDRIA COSTA
  • LUCIANO DA SILVA FACANHA
  • Data: 10-jun-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • L’objectif principal de cette thèse est celui de mettre à jour le débat philosophique autour de la relation entre l’anthropologie et la pédagogie, en mettant en évidence la formulation rousseauienne de l’homme à l’état de nature, a travers la comparaison avec l’éducation des enfants, plus précisément, avec le concept pédagogique de l’œuvre rousseauienne Émile, ou De l'éducation. La coupure de recherche ramène au modèle classique d’éducation humaine proposé par Platon, pour constater qu’il a inspiré des philosophes qui ont proposé de penser l’éducation de l’individu dans la modernité, a savoir : Montaigne, Comenius, Locke et Rousseau lui-même. Le philosophe Genevois propose dans l’oeuvre Émile un ensemble de principes qui composent sa pédagogie imprégnée par l’anthropologie, en mettant l’accent sur des questions telles que : qu’est-ce que l’homme et comment son éducation devrait-elle être? Ces questions sont posées devant une science anthropologique encore tâtonnante, qui se développe depuis la Renaissance pour atteindre son apogée au XVIIIe siècle, avec les Lumières françaises. Les idées de Rousseau provoquent dans cette science une fissure jamais imaginée pour la période.  Basé sur l’idée d’anthropologie fictive, on utilise le mythe de Glauco et se rend dans les origines de l’homme, qu’on reprend pour les employer dans l’enfant fictif, dans lequel se déroule un nouveau paradigme de la formation humaine. En traitant de l’enfance jusqu’à l’âge de douze ans, on montre les moyens de la préserver et de la protéger, pour le bien d’eux-mêmes, afin d’éviter des vices et des erreurs qui conduisent à la corruption et au malheur, à travers le travail du précepteur. Dans la ferveur du XVIIIe siècle, les sciences humaines sont influencées par la physique newtonienne, permettant d’envisager Emile comme une expérience humaine en éducation, dont la nature fournit les principes à suivre par le précepteur et pour que son élève soit soumis aux expériences d’exercice du corps et d’amélioration des sens, à travers les préceptes et les principes qui permettront de gérer l’éducation négative. Si Rousseau identifie les caractéristiques de l’enfant aux mêmes particularités de l’homme à l’état de nature, il est évident que sa conception de la pédagogie est étroitement liée à l’anthropologie, et que son idéalisation d’Emile s’intègre à la compréhension de la condition originelle de l’humanité. S’appuyant sur sa pédagogie centrée sur l’anthropologie, Rousseau cherche à développer des principes pouvant garantir ou éviter au maximum la dégénérescence et la défiguration de l’homme, a travers un processus capable de conduire les enfants à devenir des hommes autonomes face aux incitations négatives présentées par le processus social. Un homme aussi bien formé aura toutes les capacités et les conditions pour être souverain, libre et juste. Par conséquent, il formera une société plus juste et égalitaire, où les gens seront plus heureux. Selon Rousseau, penser l’enfant c’est concevoir l’homme futur.

3
  • ADRIELLE COSTA GOMES DE JESUS
  • Heidegger and the apex of metaphysics

  • Líder : ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • PAULO AFONSO DE ARAUJO
  • CLAUDIA PELLEGRINI DRUCKER
  • DIOGO CAMPOS DA SILVA
  • DAX FONSECA MORAES PAES NASCIMENTO
  • Data: 25-nov-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis aims to problematize the proposal of overcoming metaphysics presented by Heidegger and, with it, the place of his thought in the stage in which Western philosophy reaches its extreme possibility. Some critics argue that his question of being inaugurates a new mode of unveiling in the history of Western thought. And, therefore, they consider him either as a philosopher of the end of metaphysics, or as responsible for the emergence of a post-modern and post-humanist thought. We will see throughout this thesis that, despite such interpretations, Heidegger does not understand the possibility of overcoming metaphysics as a closure of the preceding history. But as a recognition of the unveiling of being as a condition for the historicity from which metaphysics unfolded and in which we are situated. With that, we will see that he is not consistent with his philosophy to think of it as an effort to break with this tradition, nor to think of the possibility of an epochal transition as an effort of an individual will. Such an overcoming depends on the dispositions of the being's own history.

4
  • YVES MARCEL DE OLIVEIRA SÃO PAULO
  • EMPTiNESS AND THE ABSOLUTE:

    A take about the sublime in movies

  • Líder : ROSA GABRIELLA DE CASTRO GONCALVES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALEX SANDRO CALHEIROS DE MOURA
  • GEOVANA DA PAZ MONTEIRO
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • ROSA GABRIELLA DE CASTRO GONCALVES
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • Data: 15-dic-2022


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • In some movies it seems like nothing happens. This conflict with mass cinema is a deliberate effort by filmmakers to achieve the imponderable of what haunts their characters and the world created. The imponderable is not within the reach of the figurative, otherwise it would no longer be endowed with its characteristic of ineffability. Thus, “nothing happens” is a stylistic choice of emptying for the amplification of the aesthetic senses of the film. The film perceives a world beyond its first sensory layer. The emptying we are talking about refers to Bergson’s nothingness, who understood that there was more to the idea of emptiness than to the idea of existence, since the first includes the second plus its negation. However, the stylistic choice for emptying goes beyond suggestibility: it establishes the presence of that imponderability impossible to be figured. The stylistic emptying then makes an ideological cut, presenting ineffable ideas that do not belong to analytical understanding, but to intuition. The latter is the field of cinematographic affection, the cosmos-creating machine that not only perceives but also feels the mishaps of the new world. These ideas are made present in this absolute immediacy, that is, in this immediacy that brings together the past and the present in a future that is being built. The absolute is the vital sap of a changing duration while it lives, released into its freedom. We conclude that the sublime is the feeling of presence of the imponderable idea, which is absolute.

2021
Disertaciones
1
  • Marcelo Vinicius Miranda Barros
  • THEORY OF RECOGNITION IN SARTRE: BODY AND INTERSUBJECTIVITY

  • Líder : MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • Luciano Donizetti da Silva
  • MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 01-feb-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The  path  to  a  possible  reflection  on  a  struggle  for  recognition  in  Sartre  was,  for  us,  from the  human  body  in  the  sartrian  perspective.  However,  before,  we  provide  some  Sartrian concepts;  we  go  through  the  issue  of  conflict  -  objectifying  or  being  objectified  through the  eyes  of  the  other;  we  approach  Hegelian  thinking  based  on  Sartrian  reading  and carry  out  a  brief  analysis  between  Sartre  and  Hegel  with  regard  to  the  recognition  of  the other.  Furthermore,  this  research  required  us  to  make  distinctions  between  the  concepts of  recognitions,  which  are  present  in  both  Sartre  and  Hegel,  leading  us  to  analyze  the ontological  recognition  in  Sartre  as  critical  to  the  gnosiological  recognition  and,  finally, the  place  of  the  body.  The  body,  at  a  given  moment,  became  relevant,  since  this  whole examination  would  be  abstract  if  it  were  not  present.  Then,  we  investigate  how  the  body is  present  in  intersubjectivity,  understanding  that  it  offers  concreteness  for  the  struggle for  recognition  that,  here,  came  from  consciousness  in  Hegel,  passing  through consciousness  in  Sartre  and  ―ending‖  in  the  sartrian  body.  Thus,  we  conclude  that Sartre's  philosophy  allows  a  discussion  about  the  struggle  for  recognition,  a  discussion that  is  very  current  in  the  philosophical  sphere.  Sartrian  thought  observes  the circumspection  of  the  body,  which  expresses  concreteness  in  intersubjective relationships:  without  the body, there  is no  recognition of the  other.

2
  • Bruna Santos da Silva
  • THE PARADOX OF FREEDOM IN SARTRE: THE TACITEDEHUMANIZATION

  • Líder : ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • LUIZ DAMON MOUTINHO
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 11-feb-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This essay aims to analyze the condemnation of man to freedom defended by J-P Sartre in Being and Nothingness, to maintain that freedom deliberately dehumanizes human people. And, we assume that such condemnation becomes a problem, therefore, the priority of freedom seems to delegates man to care only about the formation of his values and with their release from the bonds of society. So, the man does not realizes that he is transforming human people into objects to satisfy his personal desires. Therefore, we question whether the priority of the man's freedom would be carry out their liberation or dehumanize people.

3
  • RUI BENEVIDES PRATES
  • Transfiguration: a methodological anti-scepticism in the Romanian work of Emil Cioran

  • Líder : KLEVERTON BACELAR SANTANA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • Bruno Martins Machado
  • FLAMARION CALDEIRA RAMOS
  • KLEVERTON BACELAR SANTANA
  • Data: 16-feb-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This research aims to define and dimension the idea of transfiguration in Emil Cioran's Romanian work, with the more specific objective of elucidating the ways that this thought explores the movement to overcome skepticism as a psychological state, without, however, disqualifying it as a theory of knowledge. For this purpose, we have structured the path of our investigation based on two fundamental questions: (i) What is the cioranian conception of skepticism? (ii) What is the concept of transfiguration? By defining them, we can conclude that transfiguration is a proposal to overcome skepticism, that is, a methodological anti-skepticism.

4
  • ANDRÉ FIGUEIREDO BRANDÃO
  • The social genesis of moral values in last Lukács

  • Líder : VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANA SELVA ALBINATI
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 17-feb-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The difficulties of the contemporary philosophical debate in dealing with specifically moral problems, as they are enunciated by the obstacles of individuation developed by the new social relations, in addition to the opportunistic use of morality by neofascism, go back to the diagnosis of the hungarian philosopher György Lukács about the need for the constitution of a tertium datur for the reduction of ethics to the alternatives of relativistic historicism and metaphysical dogmatism. Imbued with such perspective, the marxist philosopher projected an ambitious theoretical itinerary around the understanding of morality, combining historicity and social objectivity. The death of the author, however, bequeathed to posterity only the background work for further ethical reflection, an ontology of the social being, and the notes organized by the philosopher to guide his own writing. The aim of this study is to compare these remaining texts, so that Lukács' contribution to the understanding of the social genesis of moral value can be systematized. For that, the reconstruction of his thinking starts from the conditions of human self-production, which consolidate the use value as the first form of valuation, following his mediation with the development of sociality that provides bases for the formation of moral value and, finally, the problems related to the historical and objective development of morality and the discontinuities of its appropriation by social individuals. Thus, we intend to systematize the status that Lukács gives to moral value, through its social genesis, placing it in the complex of complexes of human action.

5
  • TATIANA SOUZA CORREIA
  • SENSE OF JUSTICE AND NORMATIVITY: THE ROLE OF MORAL FEELINGS IN THE THEORY OF JUSTICE AS EQUITY BY JOHN RAWLS

  • Líder : GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANDRE JACQUES LOUIS ADRIEN BERTEN
  • GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • NYTHAMAR HILARIO FERNANDES DE OLIVEIRA JUNIOR
  • Data: 02-mar-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The aim of this dissertation is to analyze the role of moral feelings in the theory of justice as equity as proposed by the philosopher John Rawls. In Chapter VIII of A Theory of Justice (1971), Rawls introduces the idea that moral feelings are important to guarantee social stability in well-ordered societies. In Political liberalism, Rawls reviews some points of the theory of justice as equity, however, he remains firm in his main ideas. It is possible to see a considerable advance between A theory of justice and Political liberalism, since in political liberalism Rawls defends a political conception of justice without refers to current moral conceptions in society. The sense of justice in political liberalism is presented as a social virtue indispensable to achieve a superimposed consensus. Moreover, the sense of justice remains linked to the issue of social stability. The role of the sense of justice in both works is mediate possible conflicts and disagreements inherent to all democratic social system. Thus, this research analyzes how moral feelings, as the sense of justice, can intermediate the conflict of interests between individuals and groups in contemporary democratic societies.

6
  • BRENDA OLIVEIRA DO ESPÍRITO SANTO
  • The Status of Sensibillity in the Intellectual Update Process: The Notion of Materia Causae

  • Líder : MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • RODRIGO GUERIZOLI TEIXEIRA
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • ROBERTA MAGALHAES MIQUELANTI
  • Data: 17-sep-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation aims to expose how Thomas Aquinas qualifies the causal relationship between sensible knowledge, specifically ghosts, and the intellectual activity now expressed in the concept of materia causae. In the Summa Theologiae, question 84, article 6, Aquinas admits the concept of materia causae in opposition to the notion of total and perfect cause of intellectual knowledge as a way of safeguarding the maxim that a corporeal thing cannot act on an incorporeal thing. Thus, the relationship between phantoms and intellectual activity establishes a paradox when we consider the principle established by Aquinas. Therefore, to philosophically demonstrate that ghosts are the cause of intellectual knowledge, we will analyze Aquinas' comments to book V of Metaphysics by Aristotle, De Causis and De principiis naturae ad fratrem Sylvestrum, in order to understand how Aquinas conceives the notion of cause and its axioms. From the notion of instrumental agent treated in De Verit. q. 10, a. 6, add. 7 and, furthermore, from the elasticity that characterizes the notion of cause in the Corpus Thomisticum, is possible to affirm that ghosts are the cause of sensible knowledge, without contradicting the principle that limits the action of a corporeal thing on an incorporeal thing.

7
  • JEAN PANTOJA SANTOS
  • A study of the existence of time in Pseudo Thomas Aquinas' Opusculum de Tempore

  • Líder : MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CARLOS EDUARDO DE OLIVEIRA
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • ROBERTA MAGALHAES MIQUELANTI
  • Data: 18-nov-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • In the present research I propose the analysis of an occasion of reception of Aristotle's Physics in the 13th century, the opuscle De tempore written by Pseudo Thomas Aquinas. I treat the De tempore as a special case of reception of Aristotelian physics, whose content corresponds to the discussion presented by the philosopher in book IV of the work. For its analysis, first, it is discussed how the De tempore stands out in relation to the tradition of commentaries on the Physics and other forms of presentation of the concept of time, this includes its authorship, structure and development of concepts. Secondly, the Commentary on the Sentences of Thomas Aquinas is considered, with incursions on the Commentary on Physics by Averroes, signaling aspects present in the Thomistic theory of time that later figure in his Commentary on Physics, and, consequently, in the De tempore. Finally, I deal with the discussion present in Thomas Aquinas' Commentary on Physics, and its development in the first chapter of the De tempore, which concerns the existence of time outside the soul. That said, I analyze the De tempore by Pseudo Thomas Aquinas, especially the relationship between time and soul, in the context of the reception of Aristotle's Physics by th the scholasticism, as well as its relationship with the texts that would have originated the opuscle, the commentaries on Physics by Thomas Aquinas, Albert the Great and Averroes.

8
  • GUSTAVO NEGREIROS OLIVEIRA TEIXEIRA
  • IDEALITY AND EMANCIPATORY EXPERIMENTATION OF FREEDOM: A CRITIQUE OF AXEL HONNETH'S CONCEPT OF SOCIAL FREEDOM

  • Líder : LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • HÉLIO ALEXANDRE DA SILVA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 15-dic-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The aim of this dissertation aims to present a critique of Axel Honneth’s theory of freedom,
    which is developed in his work Freedom’s Right: The Social Foundations of Democratic Life.
    Unlike other models of freedom, such as negative freedom and moral freedom, Honneth,
    through the use of the method of normative reconstruction, defends the idea that the realization
    of freedom, that is, its process of normative experimentation, is a linked to the model of social
    freedom. Such defense, in general terms, occurs for two reasons: the first is because social
    freedom is the social precondition of human action; the second reason is because the social
    ethos of social freedom, which is Democratic Ethical Life, attests that we are free because they
    and they are involved in a series of institutionalized social spheres whose normative task is
    internal to social recognition and individual freedom of each individual. This interpretation of
    human freedom suggested by the German philosopher, however, presents two problems: the
    first problem is that Honneh’s reading of the functioning of the Normative Reconstruction
    method leads to the fact that the normadeja sediment of the socidica spheres has an idealist
    perspective; as a result, the second problem arises because the author disregards that
    Democratic Ethical Life is an instance of social life that produces and reproduces social
    injustices, that is, that engenders forms of Social Pathologies. The hypothesis that might solve
    these problems, and that I will defend, is the following: the cooperative cultivation of social
    freedom can be better developed from the nexus between education and social philosophy,
    where the first element helps in the experimentation of the purpose of the second element, which
    is the democratic realization of the good life.

Tesis
1
  • CAMILA DE SOUZA EZIDIO
  • The Natural Law in Thomas Aquinas: from nature to civitas.

  • Líder : MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALFREDO CARLOS STORCK
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • JOSÉ FRANCISCO PRETO MEIRINHOS
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • ROBERTA MAGALHAES MIQUELANTI
  • Data: 26-ene-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The result of a study on the concept of natural law in Thomas Aquinas was on the analysis of the so-called Treatise on Law of Summa Theologica I-II pars. From the moral and epistemological conception of a set of laws the task was undertaken to demonstrate the political character that the concept of natural law incures through the transit of human nature from its state of sociability to that of politicity. In fact, natural law transits from the social sphere, in which it acts as a moral rule conducting human action, to acting as a political rule in the sphere of dominium in civitas, as part of the legal structure composed on human law, justice and the different types of rights. In a preliminary way, this investigation has inferred the analysis of some moments and authors of the history of philosophy, such as, Aristotle, Augustine and Cicero, who were characterized as keys to reading not only the concept of natural law, but the moral and political theory of Thomas Aquinas. 

2
  • CRISTIAN ARAO SILVA DE JESUS
  • ILLUSIONISM AND SOCIAL CONTROL: A STUDY OF CAPITALISM'S MENTAL MANIPULATION MAGIC

  • Líder : MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DEBORAH CHRISTINA ANTUNES
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • SERGIO AUGUSTO FRANCO FERNANDES
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 19-oct-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • Based on the assumption that human beings are not completely rational and are not immune to external influence, the intention here is to analyze the mechanisms that allow influencing behavior and, more specifically, those used in capitalism for the purpose of social control. From the concepts developed by Marx, Freud and their heirs of Critical Theory, the fundamentals of social manipulation and some characteristics of the subject of capitalism, a product of these subjectivity formation techniques, are presented. Allied to this, the very tools that allow the exercise of subjective control are analyzed. The thesis brings into question how advertising, based on the knowledge bequeathed by psychoanalysis, created a structure that made it indispensable for any enterprise and enabled the creation of a machinery to influence behavior. Furthermore, it also discusses how technology has updated manipulation mechanisms through new forms of advertising on social medias and the creation of a way of life based on technological rationality. In this way, the mechanisms of social control are examined, initially in their most fundamental aspects, and investigated in their unfolding, according to the evolution of capitalism.

3
  • Juliomar Marques Silva
  • THE PROBLEM OF RATIONAL DISAGREEMENT AMONG PEERS: A DEFENSE OF THE CONCILIATORY ATTITUDE OF HUMBLE INTELLECTUAL

  • Líder : WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • PLINIO JUNQUEIRA SMITH
  • DANILO MARCONDES DE SOUZA FILHO
  • GUADALUPE REINOSO
  • FELIPE ROCHA LIMA SANTOS
  • GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • TIEGUE VIEIRA RODRIGUES
  • WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • Data: 08-dic-2021


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis inquires about the problem of rational disagreement between epistemic peers. Recently, there is much discussion in epistemology on what would be our epistemic duty in peer disagreements. In others words, the philosophy wants to know what is the rule, the norm, or the rational attitude we should follow in contexts of disagreement. About this question, many pieces of literature arose and several theoretical positions consolidate as an alternative to this problem. For many authors, called conciliationists, disagreement works as a kind of epistemic defeater, for this reason, both parts should re-evaluate their own belief and give equal weight to the opposite belief. Other authors, however, defend a kind of non-conciliationism, for this perspective, we can be steadfast and we can ignore the opponent, the disagreement does not defeat the previous justification we have for the belief. Besides these extreme positions, lately are appearing in the debate many intermediate positions. Furthermore, many problems and objections are directed to each part involved in this debate. The first three chapters of the thesis bring a general discussion on this debate, in these chapters I discuss the main positions – their arguments and their problems. In the fourth and last chapter, I defend a personal position, this one says that in face of a peer disagreement we should have a conciliationist attitude of intellectual humility. This intellectual attitude is conciliationist because understanding that a disagreement with an epistemic peer can affect our own belief, then we should revise our own justification and consider the opposite belief. It is intellectually humble because makes us to recognize our own intellectual limitations. Different from others conciliationist positions, this attitude of humility is not exactly a universal principle, it is more precisely a kind of disposition or intellectual posture. Thus, the conciliationist attitude of intellectual humility in face of peer disagreement could deal better with some objections that affect traditional conciliationism.

     

    Keywords: Disagreement. Epistemic Peers. Intellectual Humility.

2020
Disertaciones
1
  • YONETANE DE FREITAS TSUKUDA
  • FREUD AND THE PROBLEM OF LANGUAGE IN ABOUT THE CONCEPTION OF APHASIAS

  • Líder : CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • FÁTIMA SIQUEIRA CAROPRESO
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • Data: 29-ene-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This dissertation addresses the problem of language in the early Freudian thought, focusing on the monograph On aphasia(1891), a work in which Freud takes his first step towards the construction of metapsychology. In his work, he elaborates a critique of Wernicke and Lichtheim's localizationist theories for language disorders, as well as to the Meynert’s general theory about the functioning of the nervous system. Freudian criticism consists in refuting all the theses that would serve as a support for localizationist theory, which resulted in the construction of a new way of thinking about the interactions between the brain and the psychic function of language and, therefore, of the psyche as a whole. Thus, the Freudian critique of localizationism also demanded a thorough analysis of the psychology underlying the localizationist theses and their due reformulation. This rupture was essential for the constitution of psychoanalysis, since at this point Freud revealed the possibility of building a speculative “psychological” theory, exempt from an immediate concern about anatomical determinism. The problem that drives our study questions the way in which the criticism undertaken by Freud to neurology at the end of the 19th century allowed him to appropriate and subvert the psychology implicit in its foundations, leading him to the formulation of a new representation theory which, in general terms, can be identified as one of the foundations of psychoanalysis in it’s theoretical and clinical dimensions. We understand that the concept of representation forged by Freud can be explained as one of the Grundbegriffs of metapsychological theory, finding it throughout his thought, and it is essential to clarify this concept for the proper understanding of the epistemological contours of psychoanalytic discourse as an original field, as well as the model of psyche involved in its theoretical developments.

     

2
  • LUCIENE BRAGA RAMOS BORGES
  • THE CONFLICT OF INTERSUBJECTIVITY IN THE book Being and Nothingness
  • Líder : MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • THANA MARA DE SOUZA
  • Data: 25-mar-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • Sartre approaches intersubjectivity, in his work Being and Nothingness (1943/2014), taking into
    consideration the perspective that man, described by him as human reality, relates to other men in a
    fundamentally conflictive way. We opt, following Sartre himself, to use in the Dissertation the term
    “human reality” in most of the times that we refer to man.2 Other times, depending on the context, we
    use the terms subject, subjectivity, being-for-itself (ontologically) or conscience, but each of the terms
    will be placed in due time and fully related to the context mentioned in the topic or chapter in which it
    will be approached. That said, as it appears, the conflictive way we talked about above, a result of the
    encounter between human realities, concentrates in the manner we encounter, fundamentally, the
    other, as constitutive of our being-in-the-world, and in the fact that this constitution reflects itself on
    the concrete world of our actions. This would imply, in any case, in the encounter between freedoms,
    in a constant process of transcendence of their original situations. The radicality of freedom would be
    in the core of the conflict. The question about how each human reality exists in the world, in the
    presence of the other, and how Sartre explains this constant tension, that follows the encounter, must
    accompany us as a guiding thread in the process of writing this Dissertation, since we strive to
    understand if this tension, in human relations, for Sartre, means isolation and dehumanization. We
    consider, first, that, Sartre addresses, above all, man as being-in-the-world, conscience understood as
    freedom; second, the encounter with the other as contingent; third, human actions as free and,
    consequently, as responsible, therefore ethical; and, fourth, that it is based on overcoming, that is, of
    transcendence of these contingencies, that it can be expected the accomplishment of humanism, as
    Sartre defends in Existencialism is a Humanism (1946/2010), his most famous lecture. In the final
    considerations, we will have a dialog with Franklin Leopoldo e Silva, presenting his analysis of the
    sartrean humanism, described by him as hard humanism.

3
  • JUNE ALFRED MELO ALVES
  • FUSION FREEDOM: ENGAGEMENT AS ANTI-INSTITUTIONAL REUNIFICATION
  • Líder : MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • ANDRE CONSTANTINO YAZBEK
  • Data: 26-mar-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present work aims to draw a possible reading of how to understand the concept of
    engagement in Sartre from his work Critique of dialetical reason, published in 1960. To this
    end, we initially sought to delineate how this concept is defined within the heart of thought
    sartrian of the 40’s, in which he largely refers to his ethical-political proposal the notions
    elaborated ih his onto-phenomenological treatise Being and Nothingness (1943). Subsequently,
    we present the conceptual plot contained in the Critique, in which Sartre, seeking to scrutinize
    the inteligibility of dialectical reason, establishes a dalogue between existetialism and marxism.
    Finally, taking up the notion of engagement int the 1940s and in light of the concepts presented
    in the Critique, we propose the ethical-politicla direction os engagement as anti-institutional
    regrouping.

4
  • RAFAEL AZEVEDO DOS SANTOS
  • SUBJECT OF DESIRE IN THE GENEALOGY OF MICHEL FOUCAULT'S SUBJECTIVITY: THE NOTION OF THE BODY IN THE PASSAGE BETWEEN CLASSIC GREECE AND THE HELENISTIC-ROMAN PERIOD

  • Líder : MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • GIOVANA CARMO TEMPLE
  • MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • Data: 01-sep-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The object of study of this dissertation goes through the notion of body in the genealogy of
    subjectivity by Michel Foucault in three distinct moments in the light of the so-called
    Foucaultian ethical phase: (i) the development of dietetics arts in relation to the body in
    classical antiquity; (ii) the practices and procedures, which emerged at the height of the
    “culture of the self” in the Hellenistic-Roman period, through which it was possible, under the
    sign of self-care, to increase attention in relation to the body; and finally, (iii) ascetic practices
    (askesis) as a mechanism for assimilation and incorporation of true discourses. For this, we
    use the Foucaultian analyzes regarding the moral and medical knowledge of Antiquity as a
    support for the development of the processes of subjectivation.

5
  • MARCELO BARRETO DOS SANTOS
  • THE MORAL BALANCE IN EPICTET
  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MARCUS REIS PINHEIRO
  • ROBERTO BOLZANI FILHO
  • Data: 02-oct-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This research aimed to formulate a possible answer to the following question: what is the criterion that, in Epictetus' view, should be used to carry out correct moral evaluations? Reflections on morality occupy a fundamental place in the lessons of the philosopher from Nicopolis, however, although a good part of his prescriptions imply the application of a criterion in the formation of moral opinions, it is not possible to find in these lessons a systematic presentation of this criterion. For this reason, the practical exercises that seem to form the axis of Epictetus' philosophy, as well as the examples and images that permeate his thought, were the main source in which we sought to identify the specific characteristics of the moral criterion, through analysis , in dialogue with the interpretations of some commentators. Some of the exercises investigated in more depth were the withdrawal from external stimuli to internally recognize the innate notions that refer to moral concepts and are designated as prenotions, and the practice of distinguishing between what is and is not under our charge. With regard to images and analogies, the most relevant examination for the research was on the implications of the scale metaphor and the analogy between moral evaluations and medical diagnoses. Thus, the reflections elaborated during the research made it possible to recognize the following general characteristics as belonging to the moral criterion: i) the moral criterion corresponds to an assertion resulting from the articulation of pre-notions; ii) the same criterion must be replicable in similar contexts; iii) the way in which moral criteria is used is improved through habit.
6
  • Gilson Damasceno Linhares
  • From sensitive apprehension to intelligible knowledge in Thomas Aquinas

  • Líder : MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANTONIO JANUNZI NETO
  • CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • ROBERTA MAGALHAES MIQUELANTI
  • Data: 21-oct-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present work aims to analyze in an initial way the interpretative debate about the relationship between concept and object in the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas. The emphasis of the debate is on the interpretative opposition between Direct Realism and Representationalism, with regard to the notion of similarity. Thomas presents the concept as a similarity through which we know the external object. Realistic interpretation understands that the term similarity should be read as a relationship of formal identity, between concept and object. Representationalism interprets the concept as a similarity, in the sense that the concept is a mental representation of the essence of the external object. To reach this debate, we have developed an epistemological path that aims to demonstrate, as Thomas knows, the human being. Initially we define what it means to know for Thomas, from there we present the double way in which the human being apprehends the external world. First we engage in sensible apprehension through the senses. Subsequently the intelligible apprehension of bodies, which results in the formation of the concept in the intellect. Only after the conceptual formation in the intellect can we analyze the interpretative debate about the formal relationship between concept and object.

     

     

7
  • REINALDO BATISTA DOS SANTOS FILHO
  • Freedom and Authority - a possible reconciliation

  • Líder : DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • RENATA REVERENDO VIDAL KAWANO NAGAMINE
  • RENATO FRANCISQUINI TEIXEIRA
  • Data: 27-nov-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • It´s perceived that both propaedeutic commentators of Hannah Arendt´s books and her more conceptual critics, make such a characteristic and punctual approach between the authority and the freedom, that generally, it´s suspected, it up hiding ends any possibility of the affinity of these concepts. In general lines, this dissertation is guided by the objective of clarifying the possible conciliation between the concepts of authority and freedom in Hannah Arendt´s political philosophy. Books of the 60, notably  On revolution (1963) and Between past and the future (1968), and also some of her essays, in which Arendt asserts that, if on the one hand, the ancient régime distanced the freedom public from men, the seventeenth-century revolutions faced difficulties in an attempt to conceive another anchor reference for a new political authority whose purpose would be to ensure the revolutionary spirit of participation. From a theoretical point of view, it is understood that, when trying to reconcile authority with republican freedom, some modern philosophers ended up denying authority and making full freedom impossible. For Hobbes, but also for Rousseau, authority is understood around the concept of sovereignty. For if for the former authority corresponded to the Sovereign properly constituted and immune to any challenge, for the second, the authority corresponded to the people themselves, who, as a result of a "General Will", ended up being defined in terms of sovereignty. Freedom in Hannah Arendt's work is participation in the affairs of politics, and it is through her that the entire revolution is built. However, if in theory and in practice the establishment of the new republican authority caused a certain impediment to republican freedom, Arendt is based on the actions of the revolutionary council system and proves this incompatibility to be false. To justify this claim, we return to the approach of the sense of politics in the face of the emergence of the totalitarian regime and its source of authority. We also look at how the relationship of the authoritarian regime appears in Hannah Arendt's thinking. Finally, we analyze the relationship between the revolutionary freedom of the council system and the new republican authority in the form of a constitution. Given the above, we believe we can suggest that, despite the concept of sovereignty, Arendt admits a link of conciliation between public authority and freedom

Tesis
1
  • TIAGO MEDEIROS ARAUJO
  • RAÍZES DA INSTITUCIONALIDADE:
    UMA TIPOLOGIA FILOSÓFICA E UMA CONTRIBUIÇÃO TEÓRICA

  • Líder : JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALESSANDRO SERAFIN OCTAVIANI LUIS
  • CARLOS SÁVIO GOMES TEIXEIRA
  • JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • WILSON DA SILVA GOMES
  • Data: 26-ago-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis has as its theme the roots of institutionality. It makes a question about which philosophical ideas allow us to think about human willingness to create and conserve institutions, and it goes in two fronts. First, it consists in a presentation of a binary typology of philosophical ideas about the subject. Each conceived type composes an institutionalist position that concerns a central problem. Inmanential institutionalism, which has authors as G.W.F. Hegel, Arnold Ghlen and Émile Durkheim, deals with the challenge of deinstitutionalization: imminent danger to dissolution that attacks the link and the institutional durability. It sustains that the roots of institutionality are on the reason effectuate in customs, on the ethos of reciprocity or at the social solidarity, ideas that converge to the thesis according to which the main attribute of institutions is stability. Transcendentalist institutionalism, which has authors as Cornelius Castoriadis and Roberto Unger, deals with the problem of hyperinstitutionalization: the threat of current institutional apparatus autonomization. It defends that the roots of institutionality are in the imaginary creator, in historicaççy frozen conflicts or on the normalization of domination, ideas that converge to the thesis according to which institutions can be thought of by its plasticity. The main goal of this front is theming. The second front is the formulation of an theoretical contribution essay that dialogues with these types but which starts from the problem that will be presented as a feature of brazilian institutional experience, that is, semi-institutionalization: the historical trend to make possible a conflictual coexistence between official institutional order and para-institutional order. To deal with this problem one requires identifying the roots of institutionality in the commitment that coming from adherence and in the personhood that projected as material autonomy.

2
  • GEDEÃO MENDONÇA DE MOURA
  • THE CONCEPT OF MAN AND THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SCIENCE AND METAPHISICS IN MARX
  • Líder : MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • EDUARDO FERREIRA CHAGAS
  • JADIR ANTUNES
  • Data: 13-oct-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The preoccupation with Man [Mensch] is very present in Marx's youth writings. He finds to establish a concept that accounts for what can be called human essence [menschliche Wesen] or species-being [Gattungswesen]. As this concept also contains what the human being isn’t yet, or rather, what the human being is only potentially, it seems to be an a priori concept. Therefore, this concept isn’t strictly linked to materialistic data and aspects, as Marx wants us to believe when he says that his theory must be based on “real premises” that can be “verified in a purely empirical way” (MARX & ENGELS, 2010d, p. 31). This difficulty, however, isn’t restricted to Marx's youth work. In the Grundrisse, for example, he explicitly uses the expression “species-being [Gattungswesen]”. In Capital, on more than one occasion, he uses the term “human nature [menschliche Natur]”. Furthermore, at various moments in his mature work, Marx continues to treat social and economic reality as divided into two areas, namely, the scope of appearance [Schein] and the scope of essence [Wesen], thus resuming fundamental categories of metaphysics, without which, perhaps, his critique of political economy wouldn’t have been possible. Given this, it is possible to formulate the following questions: what’s the place of the concept of man in Marx's mature work? To what extent is this concept related to the problem of the human essence of youth works? Even he declares himself to be a materialist thinker, wouldn’t Marx still be a tributary of metaphysics because he doesn’t completely abandon certain concepts and categories specific to that form of thought? Nevertheless, does this not appear as a problem within your new [materialist] conception of the world, which is established precisely to oppose the many idealistic conceptions of your time? Thus, it appears that Marx's theoretical endeavor isn’t just based on scientific grounds, and as far move away as possible from the terrain of metaphysics. The object of this research, therefore, is the concept of man in Marx's work, which ends up unfolding in a reflection on some aspects of the relationship between science and metaphysics. Thus, the analysis of that concept is only the first step trying to point critically to other metaphysical aspects of his theory.

3
  • ANA MARGARETE BARBOSA DE FREITAS
  • EPISTEMIC AGENCY, NATURALISM AND VIRTUES

  • Líder : WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALEXANDRE MEYER LUZ
  • FELIPE ROCHA LIMA SANTOS
  • GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • LUIS FERNANDO MUNARETTI DA ROSA
  • TIEGUE VIEIRA RODRIGUES
  • WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • Data: 27-nov-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This thesis aims to analyze the concept of epistemic agency, that is, the role of the cognitive agent in the achievement of epistemic goals. The epistemic agency is one of the central topics of discussion in contemporary epistemology, being an essential element for the foundation of Ernest Sosa's Epistemology of Virtues, which understands human cognitive performances as intellectual virtues. The development, in recent decades, of research in the field of Cognitive Psychology, has supported the arguments of naturalistic philosophers who challenge the image of the epistemic agent as defended by Sosa and point to the impossibility of having an agency related to the processes of belief formation. Taking this context into account, I submit the main statements defended by Sosa in his epistemological project to the counter arguments offered by naturalist philosophers such as Hillary Kornblith and Joëlle Proust, reaching the conclusion that the picture sketched by Sosa for the epistemic agency lacks empirical plausibility and therefore, it does not offer an adequate response to the role of the cognitive agent in satisfying epistemic goals. Then, based on Proust's conceptions about the structure of mental actions, I present a model of epistemic agency that seeks to attend both the normative project of epistemology and naturalistic intuitions about human cognitive functioning. The acceptance to this perspective on epistemic agency leads to a more realistic view of the epistemic role of human agents and to an understanding of epistemic normativity aimed at epistemic-motivational purposes.

4
  • DANIELA SZWERTSARF
  • Subjectivity, Truth and Literature: Crisis of the dualist definition of Human Being and its resonance in The Passion According to G. H., by Clarice Lispector

  • Líder : RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ALICE MARA SERRA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • PEDRO DOLABELA CHAGAS
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • RICHARD THOMAS ELDRIDGE
  • Data: 18-dic-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The aim of this work is to seek out ways of understanding the concept of human being, but setting out from non-scientific bases. The mental model inherited from the Cartesian philosophy paved the way for the scientific knowledge of the human. Modernity and the advancement of technology reinforce the Cartesian heritage and its dualistic explanation, in which the body and its movement are explained in a disenchanted way, as mere mechanisms. The mental realm also became object of scientific explanation, being described by regularities and causal laws. However, this condition creates paradoxical situations that are unbearable for human consciousness. Thus, it is possible to think of forms of human truth based on intelligibility, intuition and expression, and not on the formulation of sentences that follow the scientific protocols of knowledge. For this, it is necessary to understand the expressive dimension of language. The way we attribute meanings to different everyday situations is anchored in the convention of cultural practices. Narrative here is understood within the spectrum of the expressive speech act. The narrator is the source of meaning in a narrative. The meaning of the narrative does not stem from the logical-causal link among events, but from its ability to express emotions. The truth and the sense, therefore, are necessaril y expressed by a subject imbued with experiences and emotions. This truth is appropriate and legitimate, not opposing to objectivity. Therefore, the way human beings attribute meaning to their experiences is neither scientific nor rational. We attribute meanings through intuition and attunement to cultural practices. Literature, therefore, can be understood as a cultural practice through which we attribute meaning to experiences. Literature achieves universality since it is anchored in a grammar of values shared by culture. Thus, the literary text expresses more than an individual reality, finding resonance among the readers. It is possible to see in modern art several manifestations of the unbearable condition to which the dualistic and scientific explanations have led the human. The Passion According to G. H., a novel by Clarice Lispector, is read in this context. The human-nature opposition gains paradoxical contours in this work. We try to understand better these paradoxical outlines in dialogue with philosophers like Wittgenstein, Peter Hacker, Richard Eldridge, Peter Goldie and Charles Altieri.

5
  • RODRIGO ORNELAS FRANÇA
  • DIALÉTICA COMO APROPRIAÇÃO E DEVORAÇÃO: Uma interpretação filosófica da modernidade

  • Líder : JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANDRÉ LUÍS MOTA ITAPARICA
  • HILTON LEAL DA CRUZ
  • JARLEE OLIVEIRA SILVA SALVIANO
  • JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • João Cezar de Castro Rocha
  • Data: 18-dic-2020


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This research investigates the notion of appropriation in relation to modernity, based on philosophy. The fundamental thesis I seek is that, taking appropriation as the structuring of the dialectic that guided the philosophical discourse of modernity, we can offer a version of appropriation as devouration that can be supported philosophically as a perspective of modernity in its transformative and affirmative character. There is an existential sense of appropriation in post-Hegelian philosophy posed by Max Stirner, as well as an important role of the notion of appropriation in Karl Marx's transformative materialist philosophy – both starting from the Hegelian dialectic, where the concept of appropriation is inserted. Taking modernity as the time of ruptures and changes, of technical protagonism, of the autonomy of the individual and the rise of democracies, the philosophy that wants to apprehend its time and context as a matter for reflection – that is, (post) Hegelian philosophy, a transformation philosophy – will guide you as perspectives of that time. This gives rise to attitudes towards modernity: rejection or fulfillment, affirmation or denial. In the peripheral context of modernity, also starting from the Hegelian influence, Oswald de Andrade develops the suggestion of anthropophagy as a worldview. Here the transformative sense of dialectics and modernity is radicalized in a positive, anti-colonial, exuberant operation, both in an existential dimension and in an offer from a global perspective. I believe that this orientation of dialectic not explored in philosophy (that of anthropophagy) is also a path to modernity. Its limits and advantages is what this research finally wants to point out, in the form of a philosophical narrative that starts from the establishment of the philosophical discourse of modernity to what I will call a dialectic of devouring, a practical-creative anthropophagy.

2019
Disertaciones
1
  • LUIZE SANTOS DE QUEIROZ
  • PERCEPTION ET SIGNIFICATION ESTHÉTIQUE EN MUSIQUE

  • Líder : SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • MATHEUS HIDALGO
  • Data: 26-abr-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • RÉSUMÉ

     

    Il est facile de souscrire à la thèse selon laquelle le sens musical est indissociablement perceptif. Ce que nous présentons comme musique, c’est-à-dire l’apparence musicale et son sens incarné, est compris par nous, avant tout, par un effort d’abstraction. En ce sens, sur la base théorique, c'est-à-dire la phénoménologie de la perception du philosophe M. Merleau-Ponty et de son virage ontologique, nous prendrons plus systématiquement la musique et le sens musical, même si le philosophe n'a pas tardé approche. De cette manière, l’objet de la recherche est d’abord créé dans une composition musicale telle qu’elle peut être vécue à travers le processus corporel et perceptif, mais aussi dans la manière dont elle est prise dans le domaine du langage en tant qu’expression du monde, qui prend forme à travers la chanson. Dans le cadre de cette recherche, il est destiné, dans les limites des possibilités présentes, à jeter les bases d’une procédure phénoménologique et ontologique d’analyse musicale, concernant la perception et la signification, donnée dans le monde vécu à partir de l’expérience corporelle et linguistique. Nous explorerons les concepts de sensation, perception, expression, corps, schéma corporel, champ phénoménal et monde en tant que force motrice pour une discussion dans le cadre de la phénoménologie et traiterons de la façon dont ces concepts se déroulent dans le tour ontologique de l'auteur étudié, être appliqué pour penser la musique, en comprenant que Perception et Sens sont des participants à la construction du sens.

     

     

     

2
  • ALEXANDRE BARREIROS DE CARVALHO FONSECA
  • On the concept of the work of art in Arthur Danto

  • Líder : SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DIOGO GURGEL
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • Rachel Cecília de Oliveira Costa
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • Data: 28-jun-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • ABSTRACT

     

    The present dissertation has as main objective to investigate the concept of work of art proposed by Arthur Coleman Danto with the purpose of verifying its capacity to differentiate the mere things of works of art. The research will analyze, in parts, each one of the constituent elements of the concept of work of art presented by Danto and its consequent applications with the objective of differentiating works of art from mere things. As is known, Danto develops his reflections on contemporary art under the impact of the productions of some American pop art artists. This work intends to investigate the conception of work of art proposed by Danto, in view of the successive formulations of his theories and some criticisms that were made to him. Although Danto's philosophical approach to art overcomes the task of definition, I will limit the scope of this research to the definition of his concept of art and to some notions he has presented and which have somehow become well known in the contemporary discussion of difference between "works of art" and "mere real things".

3
  • LUIZ FELIPE MAGALHÃES DE MELO
  • Anthropology, morphology and metaphilosophy in Wittgenstein

  • Líder : RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • DIOGO GURGEL
  • Data: 04-jul-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The object of this dissertation is the philosophical dimension and metaphilosophical dimension of Ludwig Wittgenstein's (1889-1951) Remarks on Frazer’s Golden Bough (1967). The Remarks correspond to a collection of philosophical notes whose general relevance to the whole of Wittgenstein's work can be established: in a more superficial way, as to its philosophical dimension; and in a deeper way, as to its metaphilosophical dimension. As for the philosophical dimension of the Remarks, that is, as regards the object of Wittgenstein's philosophical investigation, the text can be read as a critique of the anthropological method employed by J. G. Frazer (1854-1941) in his masterpiece, namely The Golden Bough (1890-1915). As for Wittgenstein's method of philosophical investigation, the text can be read as an appropriation of the morphological method employed by O. A. G. Spengler (1880-1936) and a self-criticism of the old philosophical method employed by Wittgenstein in his first book of philosophy, namely, the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus (1921); but above all as an exercise in the employment of a new philosophical method, still in its most elementary condition, which would be improved throughout Wittgenstein's late philosophy, and would be declared by the philosopher himself as his greatest philosophical legacy. Thus, our object concerns not only the philosophical nature of Wittgenstein's critique of Frazer's anthropology but also the metaphilosophical nature of Wittgenstein's appropriation of Spengler's morphology and, above all, self-criticism of his own philosophy. The objective of this dissertation is to investigate the relation of Wittgenstein's critique to Frazer's anthropology and the appropriation of Spengler's morphology with the employment of his new philosophical method and his reflections on the nature of philosophy. In other words, it is a question of showing how the philosophical dimension and the metaphilosophical dimension of the Remarks overlap each other; and how we can apprehend the second from the first. Therefore, this dissertation was divided in two parts: the first, dedicated to the questions external to the text of the Remarks; and the second, dedicated to the internal questions to the text of the Remarks. The first part was divided into two chapters: one on the historical context of the intermediate period of Wittgenstein's philosophy and the purpose that led him to the writing of the Remarks; and another on the problems that occurred in the process of editing and publishing the Remarks from the Wittgenstein’s Nachlass that imply in problems relevant to their exegesis. The second part was also divided into two chapters: one on the philosophical dimension of the Remarks, that is, on Wittgenstein's critique of Frazer's anthropology; and another on the metaphilosophical dimension of the Remarks, that is, on Wittgenstein's appropriation of Spengler's morphology and the formation of a new philosophical method.

4
  • ANA LÚCIA DOS SANTOS E SANTOS
  • Practices of Freedom in Foucault's Thought
  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • GIOVANA CARMO TEMPLE
  • Data: 05-jul-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This research proposes to analyze in Foucault's thought two possible conceptions of freedom. On the one hand, politics (genealogical axis) that, through governmentality, the strategic field of power relations, implies mutual relations that make room for resistance; on the other hand, ethical freedom (ethical axis – subjective), which is presented in the examination made of the practice of freedom in late stoicism, from self-care, through regular exercises that allow the individual to to live life as art, since ethics, as a reflected practice, is also an exercise of freedom. Indeed, ethics as a practice of freedom, as something that transforms the world and oneself, occurs in the encounter with the other, far from being an solitary with the self, is realized in association with others. In this way, we will try relate ethical freedom to politics, showing how the individual practices freedom to from the care of the self, and understand how it is possible to problematize this practice of freedom as a movement of resistance, since when the individual resists the power of the other through self-practices, a variety of possibilities opens up, and this it only occurs because the individual is free. From this perspective, the game existing in the relationships takes place from the government, that is, from the conduction of conducts, and must give way to resistance movements, that is, instead of just understanding the mechanisms of driving or letting oneself be driven, it is necessary to resist it, so that there can be possibility of the development of forms of counter-conducts, which happen as opening to new subjectivities in the field of insubordination, of disobedience.
5
  • ALINE VALÉRIA RAMOS DE ALMEIDA
  • Acrasia and Ignorance in Aristotle

  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ADRIANA SANTOS TABOSA
  • GISLENE VALE DOS SANTOS
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • Data: 03-oct-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The aim of this work is to analyze akrasia and ignorance from reading NE VII.3 in the light of three issues: (i) why do we sometimes act against our better judgment while when we know what we must do? (ii) how can we refer to akrasia in terms of ignorance; and, (iii) which object (teleutaia protasis) it is related to the akratic failure, i.e., which element of the practical syllogism lies in the akratic’s subject failure: it’s a failure of understanding the minor premise or a failure on conclusion of the act? While on the one hand there’s a Socratic opinion, from  Protagoras Plato’s dialogue, that no one could act against what he knows to be correct, except by ignorance, then akrasia doesn’t exist at all; on the other hand, there’s an opinion that is entirely possible for someone, in an affected state, acts contrary to his better judgment, based on the arguments mentioned above and opinions about the phenomenon of akrasia our purpose here consist in analyze akrasia, as a conflict of desires, in order to understand why is it that despite the power of our practical intellect to leader us to practice good actions we are easily influenced by our appetites? In parallel to the Socratic argument on akrasia, we must point out in this contex what kind of ignorance is linked to this phenomenon analyzed by Aristotle. At the end, we aim to explain in a suitable form how the appetite overcomes the boulesis acting as an obstacle for the intellect.

6
  • RODRIGO GOTTSCHALK SUKERMAN BARRETO
  • Silencing as an epistemological problem

  • Líder : WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • BRENO RICARDO GUIMARÃES SANTOS
  • FELIPE ROCHA LIMA SANTOS
  • GIOVANNI ROLLA
  • Data: 25-nov-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The objective of this dissertation is to analyze silencing as an epistemological problem. The way it is understood in this work, silencing refers to a communicative phenomenon in which a sender keeps his words to himself instead of enunciating them to his interlocutor. As a linguistic problem, the harmful silence is not that derived from a strategy or deliberation in which the alleged emitter gives way in turn for his interlocutor to pronounce himself, on the contrary, it refers to an imposed silence in which the emitters are coerced not to manifest themselves. With regard to this problem as an epistemological question, the type of communicative act in question are those aimed at transmitting knowledge to other people. From Miranda Fricker's inaugural work, Epistemic Injustice: Power and Ethics of knowing (2007), a fruitful field of investigation was opened in analytical philosophy about how social relations can negatively interfere in the production, maintenance and dissemination of knowledge practices. This work is situated in the field of social epistemology and, therefore, conceives individual and collective agents within the contexts and dynamics of the real world, considering the social structures to which it is subjected - in this sense, moving away from the subject of knowledge taken in abstract by classical epistemology. Based on these considerations, the purpose of this dissertation is to understand the role of testimony in the cognitive life of other people, to analyze the epistemically dysfunctional mechanisms that induce certain individuals and groups to be silenced and, finally, to glimpse possibilities of reverting these processes through virtues and practices that promote epistemic justice, that is, the opening and inclusion of marginalized agents in epistemic practices.

    Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator

7
  • GENIVAL CARVALHO BATISTA
  • ACTION, CHARACTER AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY IN ARISTOTELES: THE CASE OF THE INTEMPERANT
  • Líder : JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • JULIANA ORTEGOSA AGGIO
  • GISLENE VALE DOS SANTOS
  • ADRIANA SANTOS TABOSA
  • Data: 12-dic-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • ok

8
  • MARCUS GABRIEL MIRANDA SANTOS

  • The Adventures of Freedom: Action and Thought in Hannah Arendt's Work

  • Líder : NANCY MANGABEIRA UNGER
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • NANCY MANGABEIRA UNGER
  • WENDEL ANTUNES CINTRA
  • Data: 16-dic-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This investigation – from the standpoint of present reality and based on Hannah Arendt's philosophical work – looks for the possible relations between the fundamental human activities of action and thinking. The careful analysis of Arendt's work, I wish to argue, be it focused on studying our mental activities or historical events and the phenomenality characteristic of the universe of action, points out the existence of a central axis for understanding what configure the peculiarity of the beings we are. This same axis is what will allow us, considering the proposed, to expose the nature of the relationships between action and thinking while trying to understand our time and the depth of the crisis we are in. Such an axis focuses on the Arendtian notion of freedom, and this notion comes to light through the hypothesis that human freedom, the central factor of our humanity, is a cyclical political exercise to which converge mutually, in harmonic tension, the activities of acting and thinking. In order to corroborate this hypothesis, are investigated, in a transversal way across the text, three dimensions of human existence taken as constitutive of the understanding of freedom here at stake: a) the metaphorical discursive language we are capable of, b) the singular personality we perform in the world and c) our faculty of reflective judgment.

Tesis
1
  • DIOGO CAMPOS DA SILVA
  • Transcendental aspects in the notion of truth around Being and Time

  • Líder : ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ACYLENE MARIA CABRAL FERREIRA
  • CLAUDIA PELLEGRINI DRUCKER
  • DENISE MAGALHÃES DA COSTA
  • GILFRANCO LUCENA DOS SANTOS
  • THIAGO ANDRE MOURA DE AQUINO
  • Data: 13-mar-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • By following the tracks left by Heidegger, we argue that metaphysical thought should be considered transcendental when: a) it understands the being as a priori; b) as condition of possibility; c) as transcendental regarding the entities and the way we deal with them; and d) when such understanding of being tends to self-foundation, which always takes place associated with a certain conception of men. Thus, the main hypotheses of this dissertation are, namely: i) Heidegger focused on Husserlian theory of truth – which take that into account as experienced and noticed identity in the act of evidence – and on Aristotelian thought regarding noetic truth, thus finding transcendental features which influenced his thinking about the truth as disclosure during the 1920s; ii) the way Heidegger exposed and dealt with truth in the first stage of his philosophy was affected by the four features of the mathematical project-of-being mentioned above. We conclude this dissertation by showing the paths pursued by Heidegger since the 1930s in order to overcome the transcendental perspective which distinguished his first notion of truth.

2
  • Rodrigo Oliveira de Araujo
  • The question of writing in the work of Walter Benjamin. 

  • Líder : SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CARLA MILANI DAMIÃO
  • EDVALDO SOUZA COUTO
  • FERNANDO GIGANTE FERRAZ
  • JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • JOÃO EMILIANO FORTALEZA DE AQUINO
  • SILVIA FAUSTINO DE ASSIS SAES
  • WASHINGTON LUIS LIMA DRUMMOND
  • Data: 12-abr-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • ARAÚJO, Rodrigo Oliveira. The question of writing in the work of Walter Benjamin. Doctoral thesis. Graduate Program in Philosophy. Universidade Federal da Bahia, Salvador, 2018.


    Walter Benjamin has found that the issue of presentation (Darstellung) has historically proven to be a problem immanent to philosophical doing in itself. The present work aims to understand how he confronted this problem in the scope of his philosophical writing. The thesis deals with this theme through three perspectives that it considers structuring in the author's work: the way in which he understood language and place of writing in this process of understanding; the place of writing in his epistemological critique, as well as in his presentation of the aesthetic concept of allegory; and, finally, the theme of philosophical writing in its connection with politics. The discussion on this connection is based on the relationship that Benjamin established with the literary experiments present in the historical vanguards of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries through his own remarkably experimental writing. The thesis intends, therefore, to offer a detailed examination of Benjamin's conceptualization of the subject of writing in philosophy, and of the way in which he faced the question by shifting, experimenting, and exercising in various ways his own activity as a writer of a very peculiar philosophy.

3
  • LAIZ FRAGA DANTAS
  • The problem of normativity in critical theory: Nancy Fraser and the contemporary debate

  • Líder : JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • FILIPE AUGUSTO BARRETO CAMPELLO DE MELO
  • HILTON LEAL DA CRUZ
  • JOSE CRISOSTOMO DE SOUZA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • Nathalie de Almeida Bressiani
  • Data: 16-jul-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • We intend to deal with the debate about the normative criterion that the contemporary Critical Theory wants to take, considering the thinking of Nancy Fraser as the axis of this debate, observing the challenges that contemporary multicultural societies present to us, the social struggles and their new conformations, late capitalism, and how the theoretical tools of this philosophical tradition can be effective in managing today's social reality. Since the emergence of Critical Theory, the question of how to base social diagnoses and justify statements about the processes of social regression, crisis and emancipatory potentials, is a defining element of the possibility of criticism. The debate covers issues such as the relationship between theory and practice, the place where the critical theorist speaks in relation to the society that analyzes, beyond the historical processes of social development, perceived through this broader picture. In order to maintain the original aim of social critique, to establish diagnoses and prognoses of societies, contemporary critical theorists face the question of how to reconcile the normative character demanded by the critic, with attention to the complex and very dynamic context of societies in capitalist democracies of our time, combining a universalist intention and with the particularity.

4
  • PEDRO DE SOUZA RODRIGUES NETO
  • Economy, Moral and Human Nature in Hume's Philosophy

  • Líder : JOAO CARLOS SALLES PIRES DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • DANIEL TOURINHO PERES
  • FERNÃO DE OLIVEIRA SALLES
  • HUGO EDUARDO ARAUJO DA GAMA CERQUEIRA
  • MARCOS RIBEIRO BALIEIRO
  • MARIANA DE ALMEIDA CAMPOS
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • PEDRO PAULO PIMENTA
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • Data: 09-ago-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The philosophy of David Hume has as one of its characteristics the fact of unifying what was traditionally thought to belong to the scope of necessity and that which belonged to the realm of freedom. Hume thinks of Nature as a unity, and although his works have internal divisions that distinguish the matters between which is relative to the understanding, which is relative to the passions and which is relative to the morals, what we perceive is that these divisions only serve to show that the scope of disciplines can be integrated under the same approach, under the same explanatory principle, just as Newton unified heavens and Earth under universal gravitation. But his thought was reformulated, and what appeared in the third book on morals in the Treatise of Human Nature is dispersed in his later synthesis in appendices to the Enquiries concerning Human Understanding and concerning the principles of Morals and in his Essays Moral, Political and Literary. In these texts we find his reflection on issues such as justice, property, contracts and a series of aspects related to Economics and Politics, understood under the treatment that he dispenses to luxury, refinement, excess and superfluous, as far as he considers them as objects at once of morals and passions. Hume’s moral sentimentalism imposes the consideration of these themes in the key of the consideration between private interest and public interest, the sovereign agency and the good of the Nation, in a reflection in which moral development is not dissociated from material prosperity. Thus, a more precise understanding of these texts promotes not only the opportunity to consider his philosophy as a totality that faces the empirical issues expressed in History, Politics and Economy, but allows us to discern the position of Hume in vivid debates of his time, in a moment when Economics was being formed as a scientific body of knowledge separated from Morals. His peculiar way of understanding human nature allowed him to formulate a series of economic considerations that do not dissociate them from moral reflection, since for Hume the passions are the human motive. Thus understood, his contributions carry the marks that characterize economics to this day: that of being a body of probable knowledge, founded rather on probability than on the certainty of internal laws known in the manner of ultimate causes; and to constitute an amalgam of descriptions and prescriptions, at the same time meant to explain economic phenomena and influence their future courses. Hume’s economic reflection thus provides elements to consider the various theoretical traditions in which contemporary Economics divides today, in as much as it points out that the operation of separation from Morals has not been definitively completed and may not be possible to do so. It poses itself as a possible synthesis; and although limited to some aspects and little served of precise calculation tools to guide political and economic actions, it already offers several elements that have continued to populate the theoretical universe of Economics, as for example the notions of utility, pleasure, excess and the importance of feelings for the explanation of economic phenomena.

5
  • MURILO GARCIA DE MATOS AMARAL
  • RUSSELL AND THE GRAMMATICS OF A SCIENTIFIC PHILOSOPHY
     
     
     
     
     
  • Líder : JOAO CARLOS SALLES PIRES DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ABEL LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • JAIMIR CONTE
  • JOAO CARLOS SALLES PIRES DA SILVA
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • RAQUEL ANNA SAPUNARU
  • Data: 27-nov-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This work explores the construction processes of a specific language to philosophy in Bertrand Russell. The aim was to understand how he determined the vocabulary and syntax of the language used in his logical atomism, with attention to the notions of existence and experience. In order to do that, I had to examine how his analysis of propositions and concepts served to this purpose. I have noted that Russell tried to guide these analyses through non-dogmatic precepts, which are align with his idea of a scientific philosophy. I have identified that his analysis of propositions seeks to break with a logic unjustifiably restricted to the subject- predicate form, which he thought to be the origin of a defective grammar and thus cause of superfluous metaphysical problems. Moreover, I have identified that his analysis of concepts always seeks to determine the supposed “most fundamental” meaning of a philosophical notion, understanding that its meaning should consist in “the nucleus” of a word’s multiples usual meanings. Thereby, he hoped to prevent a particular meaning of the word from imposing itself on the others without a reason for it. Taking the analysis of propositions and concepts under that basis, Russell tried to precisely determine the meaning of “experience” and “existence” to compose a grammar free of vagueness and ambiguity, compatible with his scientific philosophy. Regarding to “existence”, Russell defines it as a property of propositional functions. Thus, the proposition “a exists” could be best understood as “‘x is a’ is possible” or “‘x is a’ is sometimes truth”. I argue that the meaning of “existence” is further complemented by the fundamental meaning of “experience”, which can be found in the notion of acquaintance. I pointed out that “existence” and “acquaintance” are defined in symbiosis, so that all that exists in the strict sense of the word is what is known by acquaintance. The thesis structure is divided into three chapters. Chapter

    1 introduces logical atomism and shows why Russell takes it as a scientific philosophy. Chapter 2 explains its capital method – which is logical analysis – and provides two examples of analysis of propositions. Finally, Chapter 3 shows how the analysis of propositions and concepts serves to the construction of a philosophical grammar. In addition, an annex brings the translations of two texts, “Le réalisme analytique” and “Knowledge by Acquaintance and Knowledge by Description”, after a commentary on the thesis’ impact on our translation choices.

6
  • GUSTAVE CAVALCANTE MARQUES
  • PHENOMENOLOGY OF THE MEANING OF INTERCORPOREITY AS THE ORIGINAL BASIS OF SYMBOLIC PRACTICES
  • Líder : MONCLAR EDUARDO GOES DE LIMA VALVERDE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CLAUDINEI APARECIDO DE FREITAS DA SILVA
  • GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • MAURO CARBONE
  • MONCLAR EDUARDO GOES DE LIMA VALVERDE
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • Data: 19-dic-2019


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present work starts from the investigation of the statute of the relation between the body and the conscience, demonstrating how the unfolding of this relationship will enable the construction of a horizon of meaning that can be shared, establishing an opening for the intersubjectivity, which, being always inscribed within the scope of sensibility, will enable not only the individual sensible apprehension of reality data, but also the sharing of the senses elaborated through the expressiveness of the body, revealing this last as a true channel of communication. In this sense, we intend to describe the articulation between the biological dimension of the organism, its self-regulation and its unfolding into a model of integration of functions that will structure, in an integral whole and interdependent, motor skills, affectivity, sexuality, and language. This structuring will found the perfectly elaborate mental space that is the hallmark of man, which it will function as the center from which all your expressive endeavors will derive. In As a result of this integration, we will assume intercorporeality as the concrete mode of intersubjectivity, unequivocally establishing the fact that a communication originating from between the individuals operated by the sensitivity pathway. Through this movement it will be possible describe the genesis of meaning from the sensitive intertwining of the individual body, things and others, intertwining this grounding in the spontaneous experience of a world which will unfold in an articulated language - elaborated from the intersubjective elements cataloged by community experience - and its institutions derivatives. Finally, as a result of this itinerary, we intend to support the hypothesis that this spontaneous communication is only possible because we have always been connected with each other through our body so that we find in the incorporeality the dimension of our existence that sustains and from which all our symbolic practices sprout.
2018
Disertaciones
1
  • CAROL ANE MUTTI PEDREIRA

  • THE INTERPRETATIVE ACT IN PAUL RICOEUR: A ROUTE FOR RESPONSIBLE LEGAL HERMENEUTICS

  • Líder : RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • GENILDO FERREIRA DA SILVA
  • MALCOM GUIMARÃES RODRIGUES
  • ROBERTO ROQUE LAUXEN
  • Data: 20-feb-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The scope of the present work is the search for a responsible hermeneutics. We call responsible the interpretation in which the subject-interpreter, as being-in-the-world, reflects on the process of interpretation and the validity of his interpretations. We evaluate the problem that involves the conflicts of interpretations in general lines, but also specifically in the legal domain. We examine the consequences of divergent interpretations of legal norms that sometimes culminate in disparate judicial decisions, which on the one hand can generate legal uncertainty, and on the other fosters judicial creativity and the progress of law. We base our study on Paul Ricoeur's thought, in which self-understanding is a sine qua non condition for interpretation, i.e., to understand oneself is to narrate one's own existence manifested in face of the text. In order to do so, we will examine Ricoeur's Hermeneutic path of understanding, claiming that self-understanding does not stem from a solipsistic introspection, but rather is mediated by otherness and the meaning of signs. It is in this context that we raise an ethical responsibility that must guide the interpretation of legal texts, because in the context of self-understanding and in the search for narrative identity we exercise moral judgment and ask ourselves about this moral subject of imputation. This is again an opportunity to reassess ourselves at every turn as an interpreter.

2
  • ORLANDO PINHO GUERRA FILHO
  • Resistance: An Obstacle in Rorty's Path?
  • Líder : CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • CARLOTA MARIA IBERTIS DE LASSALLE CASANAVE
  • WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • SUELY AIRES PONTES
  • Data: 30-jul-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The present dissertation aims to offer an analysis of Richard Rorty's interpretation of Freudian theory, with special attention to the absence of the concept of resistance, a problem recognized by the author himself. Interested in Freud's contribution to moral reflection, Rorty elaborates his interpretation by emphasizing the conversational aspect of the psychic instances, thus softening the dimension of conflict present in Freud. Part of Rorty's argumentative strategy is to eliminate the metapsychological explanation, which makes it difficult to attempt a redescription of the concept of resistance compatible with this reading. It remains to be seen what consequences result from the absence of this concept. We argue here that such absence derives from the philosophical choices on which Rorty bases his interpretation. In this way, we try to present Rorty's assumptions regarding philosophy and interpretation. The clarification of the meaning and relevance of the Freudian concept of resistance was also developed to highlight the distinctions between Freud and the interpretation offered. The work is complemented with the support of Roy Schafer, who offers a redescription of the resistance that in our judgment is compatible with the proposal rortyana.

3
  • YVES MARCEL DE OLIVEIRA SÃO PAULO
  • THE METAPHYSICS OF CINEPHILIA: A BERGSONIAN READING OF THE CINEMA

  • Líder : ROSA GABRIELLA DE CASTRO GONCALVES
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • VINICIUS DOS SANTOS
  • ROSA GABRIELLA DE CASTRO GONCALVES
  • GEOVANA DA PAZ MONTEIRO
  • DÉBORA CRISTINA MORATO PINTO
  • Data: 03-dic-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The movies spectator has different ways of approaching a film. Some of these ways are developed socially, other are intuitively. We divided our study into two methods used not only by the spectator of movies – or cinema – but also by the philosophy. The first one is the analytic method, at the same time naturally inscribed in a person and developed socially. Naturally inscribed because instinctively we tend to trace distinctions between what we found in the world and what we found in ourselves. Socially, because the human being is naturally turned to the work in common with its peers, and during the production of this work are constructed conventions (creation of symbols, of language). The second, the intuition, is our immediate contact with the world, before the insertion of any symbol into this experience to concretize the flow. It is by intuition that we find ourselves in front of duration, the natural flow of things, without the cut of separate states. Bergson calls intuition the sympathy that drags us into the interior of things, allowing us access in its duration. In the case of cinema, it is by this sympathy that the spectator nourishes for the movie that one is allowed to enter the film, transforming it’s duration into one’s own. This distinction between two methods has as base the formulation created by Henri Bergson in a work entitled Introdução à metafísica, that allows us advance into both methods. Our goal with this distinction is to study the diverse possibilities of approach, of action, that the spectator disposes when watching and experimenting a movie. The cinephilia here studied has, therefore, the meaning of emotion: the experience of plenitude that is felt by the spectator that watches a movie. This does not happens in a passive way by the part of the spectator, oneself an agent, imagining, working intellectually to inscribe the movie into one’s own life, into one’s conscience, like the different methods of approach of a movie inserted by the kingdoms of analytic and intuition presents us. The spectator sees oneself as a creator also. Our effort of creating a metaphysical study of cinephilia as emotion brings us to see the play inherent both methods and the communion between cinephile and movie. What makes the cinephile nourish one’s emotion for the cinema beyond the moment when ceases to watch a movie. The movie continue to exist into one’s consciousness. Cinephilia is also, and above all, what drives the spectator back to the movies.

Tesis
1
  • FRANCISCO DE ASSIS SILVA

  • MARX: LITERATURE AND CRITICISM OF THE POLITICAL ECONOMY IN "THE CAPITAL"

  • Líder : MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • MAURO CASTELO BRANCO DE MOURA
  • LEONARDO JORGE DA HORA PEREIRA
  • ANTONIO DA SILVA CAMARA
  • PEDRO LINO DE CARVALHO JUNIOR
  • EDUARDO FERREIRA CHAGAS
  • Data: 11-jul-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • The presence of literature in Marx's writings dates from before his project of critique of political economy, but it is from this that literary art merges with his analyzes in an odd way, especially in "Capital", which it is linked to scientificity and re-signifies it. The analysis of the relationship between literature and the critique of political economy in "Capital" presented some possibilities of understanding literature in Marx's work: a) source of historical research; b) source of social criticism; c) source of analogies and metaphors. However, these possibilities have as main axis the exposition of the contradictions of capitalist society and the incitement to the creation of a new conception of reality distinct and in opposition to the capitalist. The reading of classical authors such as Shakespeare, Dante, Cervantes and Balzac, mentioned by Marx, was carried out with the aim of seeking to understand how Marx articulated them to his critique of political economy. In order to problematize this question in a adequately way, contemporary authors were appreciated in their works, like Lukács, Kosik, Kundera and Blanchot. The conceptions of these authors, when confronted, brought contributions that broadened the understanding of the ways in which Marx used literature both in the critique of political economy and especially in the heyday of this project: the publication of Capital. The manner in which Marx wrote "Capital," merging science and literature, gave the work a dramatic dimension. "Capital" thus became a drama about bourgeois society.

2
  • SAULO MORAES DE ASSIS

  • NATURALISM AND NORMATIVITY: THE NORMATIVE DIMENSION OF KNOWLEDGE BY NATURALIZED EPISTEMOLOGY

  • Líder : WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • FELIPE ROCHA LIMA SANTOS
  • WALDOMIRO JOSE DA SILVA FILHO
  • TIAGO ALFREDO DA SILVA FERREIRA
  • NYTHAMAR HILARIO FERNANDES DE OLIVEIRA JUNIOR
  • ALEXANDRE MEYER LUZ
  • Data: 26-jul-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • This paper aims to discuss critically the problem of epistemic normativity regarding naturalized epistemology. The thesis proposes that a naturalized epistemology can claim a normative dimension and that epistemic norms are descriptive types that acquire normative force in function of practical demands. This solely means that normative character arises in the application of epistemology descriptive results. To support this thesis, I make a broad presentation on the canonical position, referred as traditional epistemology. In contrast, bearing in mind the interests of the research, I make a thorough assessment of how some naturalistic positions understand the normative dimension. This evaluation seeks to show how the notion of justification, usually tied to that of rationality and normativity, fulfills a fundamental importance in the understanding of the epistemology that we intend to criticize. This criticism is followed by an attempt to provide another understanding of epistemic rationality, thought here as instrumental rationality, thereby abdicating any notion of justification in the characterization of normativity. This to argue that the question of the normativity of epistemology from a naturalistic perspective implies another way of understanding the evaluative dimension of knowledge, no longer in opposition, but integrated with our best empirical investigations of reality.

3
  • JULIANA DE ORIONE ARRAES FAGUNDES
  • MIND INTERPRETED: THE MODERATE REALISM OF DAVIDSON AND DENNETT

  • Líder : JOAO CARLOS SALLES PIRES DA SILVA
  • MIEMBROS DE LA BANCA :
  • ANDRE LECLERC
  • JOAO CARLOS SALLES PIRES DA SILVA
  • KARLA DE ALMEIDA CHEDIAK
  • MARCO AURELIO OLIVEIRA DA SILVA
  • RAFAEL LOPES AZIZE
  • SOFIA MIGUENS
  • Data: 01-nov-2018


  • Resumen Espectáculo
  • Interpretivism is a philosophical position that seeks to understand the mental from the third person point of view. The main representatives of this position are Daniel Dennett e Donald Davidson. In order for communication to be possible, a behavioral interpretation needs to take place, which demands the attribution of a number of mental states. In Davidson, one can find the principles of charity and rationality. According to him, one must presuppose a high rate of coincidence between someone´s beliefs and his interlocutor so that they can communicate. In the same direction, Dennett argues that the behavior of particular actors can only be explained and anticipated through the adoption of the Intentional stance, i.e., through the attribution of intentionality. Such attribution is never of isolated beliefs and desires, but of a diffused set of mental states, including a background of beliefs that are mostly true. To these authors, it is not possible to relinquish of a typically intentional vocabulary. The vocabulary of psychology, therefore, cannot be reduced to that of physics. For this reason, interpretivism is considered a form of non-reductive materialism. They advocate that the standpoint of the interpreter takes precedent over subject’s viewpoint in the search for an understanding of the mind. They call for an inversion of the starting-point: research should start from the outside to the inside; otherwise, it becomes barren, imprisoned within the subject. This text aims to present the interpretative headings of those two authors, asking if they are realistic or unrealistic concerning the mind. In this investigation, it is crucial to understand the epistemological role assigned to mental states by supporters of that approach. We claim that, for these authors, the mind have to be understood from the subject’s relations to the world and with others subjects. Dennett finds in the evolutionary history the grounds on which those relations are set. Davidson finds them in the triangulation processes present in any situation of communication. We argue that the existence of mental states cannot be denied if you adopt an interpretivist perspective, even if these mind states are not situated within the subject. The reason is that they have a crucial epistemological role. Without them, one could not give any meaning for someone else’s behavior, much less communicate with others. The ontological power does not stem, here, from them being obvious from a first-person standpoint. The reality of the states of mind, in an interpretivist position, is bound to its usefulness and indispensability. This position has the advantage of being compatible with a scientific take on the mind, because it approaches the mental from a publicly accessible viewpoint. Simultaneously, such a position acknowledges and sustains the role played by common-sense psychology, being neither eliminativist nor reductionist.

SIGAA | STI/SUPAC - - | Copyright © 2006-2024 - UFBA